Depot valuation under Rule 7 includes warehousing charges in assessable value, while penalty was deleted on the facts.

Where excisable goods are not sold at the factory gate and are transferred to a depot for subsequent sale, valuation is determined under Rule 7 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2001 on the normal transaction value at the depot. On that basis, warehousing charges collected as part of the depot sale price are includible in the assessable value for central excise duty, and the duty demand is sustained. The Tribunal also noted that, on the facts, penal action was not justified, so the penalty was set aside despite the valuation addition.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether 4% warehousing charges collected at the depot were includible in the assessable value for central excise duty; and (ii) whether penalty was sustainable.

Issue (i): Whether 4% warehousing charges collected at the depot were includible in the assessable value for central excise duty.

Analysis: Rule 7 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2001 applies where excisable goods are not sold at the time and place of removal and are transferred to a depot or other premises for subsequent sale. In such cases, valuation is to be based on the normal transaction value at the depot. As the goods were not sold at the factory gate and were sold from the Pune depot, the value adopted for sale from that depot governed assessment. The warehousing charges formed part of the price realised at the depot and were therefore includible.

Conclusion: The 4% warehousing charges were rightly included in the assessable value, and the duty demand was sustained.

Issue (ii): Whether penalty was sustainable.

Analysis: On the facts, the Tribunal found no justification for penal action even though the duty demand was upheld. The circumstances did not warrant imposition of penalty.

Conclusion: The penalty was not sustainable and was set aside.

Final Conclusion: The duty demand was affirmed on valuation of depot clearances, while the penalty was deleted, resulting in a partial allowance of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: Where excisable goods are cleared to a depot for sale and are not sold at the factory gate, valuation must be determined on the transaction value at the depot under Rule 7, and charges forming part of the depot sale price are includible in assessable value.

---