Service tax valuation turns on actual reimbursement: agent's own contractual remain includible unless paid on behalf of the principal.

For service tax valuation, expenses incurred by a clearing and forwarding agent in performing its own contractual functions are part of the gross taxable value and cannot be split out as reimbursement merely because the principal later repays them. Only payments made by the service provider on behalf of the service recipient under a legal or contractual obligation qualify as deductible reimbursements. Transportation charges for delivery using the agent's own transport may be excluded only if the agreement and records establish a true cost-to-cost reimbursement; otherwise, they remain subject to tax. The valuation issue therefore turns on whether each amount satisfies the test of actual reimbursement and requires proper segregation of includible and excludible costs.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether amounts incurred by a clearing and forwarding agent towards expenses connected with performance of its contractual obligations form part of the gross value of taxable services, and whether only legally or contractually obligated payments made on behalf of the service recipient qualify as reimbursable expenses. (ii) Whether transportation charges incurred for delivery of goods to third parties using the agent's own transport, if actually reimbursed by the principal, are excludible from the taxable value and require re-examination of the demand.

Issue (i): Whether amounts incurred by a clearing and forwarding agent towards expenses connected with performance of its contractual obligations form part of the gross value of taxable services, and whether only legally or contractually obligated payments made on behalf of the service recipient qualify as reimbursable expenses.

Analysis: The agreement required the appellant to perform several operational functions for the principal, and the record showed that many of the claimed expenses were incurred in the course of discharging those functions. Such expenditure was not automatically reimbursable merely because the principal later paid or repaid it. Reimbursement, in the legal sense, arises only where the service recipient is under a legal or contractual obligation to pay a third party and the service provider pays that amount on behalf of the recipient. Expenses that are part of the input cost of providing the service cannot be artificially split out from the service value and treated as reimbursable.

Conclusion: The bulk of the claimed expenses were rightly treated as part of the taxable value, and only qualifying reimbursement could be excluded.

Issue (ii): Whether transportation charges incurred for delivery of goods to third parties using the agent's own transport, if actually reimbursed by the principal, are excludible from the taxable value and require re-examination of the demand.

Analysis: The agreement specifically provided that where the clearing and forwarding agent used its own transport for delivery to third parties, the transportation cost would be borne by the principal and billed separately. That component was therefore capable of being treated as a true reimbursement if supported by actual cost-to-cost material. As the record did not satisfactorily establish the nature and basis of reimbursement, the demand required fresh scrutiny for segregation of actual reimbursement from other includible expenses. The authority was directed to verify the documents and recompute the tax demand accordingly.

Conclusion: The transportation component was not finally determined and had to be examined afresh on remand.

Final Conclusion: The demand was not upheld in full. The matter was sent back for recomputation after excluding only those amounts that satisfy the test of actual reimbursement, while retaining the rest in the taxable value.

Ratio Decidendi: For service tax valuation, only amounts paid by a service provider on behalf of the service recipient pursuant to a legal or contractual obligation are deductible as reimbursements; expenses incurred as part of the provider's own obligations remain includible in the gross value unless actual reimbursement on a qualifying basis is established.

---