Genuine debenture loss claim sustained where documentary evidence showed commercial substance and no sham or circular money flow.

Compulsorily convertible debenture transactions were treated as genuine where the surrounding documents showed a real business project, bank borrowings, mortgage-backed funding by the assessee, and supporting subscription, transfer, sale and valuation records. In the absence of adverse material showing sham, collusion or circular money movement, the arrangement was not regarded as a colourable device merely because the debentures were subscribed at par or the sale generated a loss against capital gains. The test of human probabilities did not override the credible documentary evidence in a distress-driven commercial setting, and the short-term capital loss, along with the claimed set-off and carry forward, was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the short-term capital loss arising from sale of compulsorily convertible debentures was genuine and allowable for set-off against long-term capital gains, or whether the arrangement was a colourable device lacking commercial substance.

Analysis: The documentary record showed that the company had undertaken a real business project, had borrowed from banks for execution, and that the assessee had raised funds by mortgaging jointly owned property to meet the liabilities. The subscription to the debentures, their transfer, and the later sale were supported by loan documents, bank statements, the subscription agreement, and an independent valuation report by a SEBI-registered merchant banker. The record did not disclose any adverse material proving sham, collusion, or money flow back to the assessee. The mere fact that the debentures were subscribed at par, or that the transaction ultimately produced a loss set off against capital gains, did not by itself establish tax evasion. In the given distress-driven commercial setting, the test of human probabilities did not displace the otherwise credible and evidenced explanation.

Conclusion: The short-term capital loss was held to be genuine, and the set-off and carry forward claimed by the assessee were upheld.

---