Mutuality principle excludes member receipts from service tax for charitable clubs and associations under the relevant period.

Amounts collected by a charitable club or association from members toward subscriptions, membership fees, deposits and allied receipts were treated as non-taxable under club or association service because the receipts arose within a mutual member relationship. The controlling principle applied was mutuality: payments collected from members for facilities, services and advantages provided to those members do not constitute taxable service receipts in the relevant period. Relying on the Supreme Court position on incorporated clubs and associations, the text states that such member-to-club receipts fell outside the service tax net. Accordingly, the demand, interest and penalties were unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether amounts collected by a charitable club or association from its members towards subscriptions, membership fees, deposits and allied receipts were exigible to service tax under the category of club or association service.

Analysis: The appellant was registered as a charitable trust and the receipts in question arose from members for providing facilities, services and advantages to those members. The governing principle applied was that receipts collected by a body from its own members, in the context of club or association activity, are not taxable where the relationship is one of mutuality. The controlling legal position was taken from the Supreme Court's ruling that incorporated clubs or associations were not within the service tax net for the relevant period, and that member-to-club receipts used for providing services to members did not attract levy.

Conclusion: The amounts collected from members were not liable to service tax and the demand, interest and penalties could not be sustained.

---