Section 50C valuation disputes require DVO reference before substituting stamp value for sale consideration in capital gains assessments

Section 50C permits adoption of stamp valuation for computing capital gains, but where that value is disputed or appears excessive, the valuation mechanism through a Departmental Valuation Officer should be used before substituting the actual sale consideration. The note also emphasises that non-participation by the assessee does not dispense with this fairness requirement, and the assessee should be given an opportunity to place evidence on valuation. In the described matter, the assessment was remitted for DVO reference and recomputation of short-term capital gain on that basis.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the assessing officer could substitute the actual sale consideration by the value adopted by the stamp valuation authority under Section 50C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, without referring the matter to the departmental valuation officer when the assessee did not participate in proceedings.

Analysis: The assessing officer invoked Section 50C and adopted the stamp valuation authority's value as deemed sale consideration to compute short-term capital gain, while the assessee did not participate in assessment proceedings. The issue requires application of statutory mechanism under Section 50C which contemplates valuation by a departmental valuation officer to determine fair market value where the value adopted by the stamp authority is disputed or appears excessive. Relevant precedent recognises that, notwithstanding non-participation by the assessee, the quasi-judicial authority should, in the interest of fairness and to avoid miscarriage of justice, give effect to the valuation mechanism by referring the matter to the valuation cell before substituting the registered value as deemed consideration. The factual matrix showed prior transaction evidence indicating a substantial variance between stamp authority value and transaction consideration, supporting the need for fresh valuation and opportunity to the assessee to produce evidence.

Conclusion: The matter is remitted to the assessing officer to refer the property to the departmental valuation officer for determination of fair market value and for re-computation of short-term capital gain in accordance with law; the appeal is allowed for statistical purposes in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Before substituting the sale consideration by the value adopted by the stamp valuation authority under Section 50C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the assessing officer must, where fairness requires, refer the matter to the departmental valuation officer for determination of fair market value and afford the assessee an opportunity to be heard, and assessment must be redetermined on that basis.

---