Dominant Character Test finds SIM issuance and activation charges constitute service consideration and are not VAT-liable.

Issuance and allotment of SIM cards and attendant activation or replacement charges were analysed under precedents treating SIMs as having no intrinsic sale value and being supplied as part of telecommunication service. The dominant-character test and the integral-supply principle were applied to treat activation and replacement fees as consideration for a taxable service rather than a sale of goods; accordingly such charges are not leviable under the VAT Act. The reassessment and VAT demand based on treating SIM issuance/activation as a sale were set aside on that legal basis.

---

---

Issues: Whether issuance/allotment of SIM cards and related activation / replacement charges are leviable to tax under the VAT Act.

Analysis: The issue was examined in light of binding precedents which hold that SIM cards have no intrinsic sale value and are supplied as an integral part of providing telecommunication services. Relevant authorities establish that charges collected for SIM cards or activation are processing/activation charges forming part of the consideration for a taxable service, and that the dominant character of the transaction is provision of service rather than sale of goods. The position in earlier decisions interpreting Article 366(12) of the Constitution of India and provisions of the A.P. VAT Act, 2005 (including Section 4(1) and Section 4(8)) was considered and applied to the facts of the petition, concluding that SIM cards and activation/replacement charges are not amenable to sales tax under the VAT Act but fall within service taxation.

Conclusion: Issuance/allotment of SIM cards and related activation/replacement charges are not leviable to tax under the VAT Act; the reassessment/order imposing VAT on such charges is set aside.

---