Tobacco leaves retain concessional GST treatment after sun-curing, grading, or butt removal when essential character remains unchanged.

Sun-curing of tobacco leaves, followed only by storage or stocking, does not change their essential character or take them out of the specific concessional entry for tobacco leaves; the goods remain taxable at 2.5% CGST plus 2.5% SGST. Grading leaves by size, colour, length, or texture is only a physical segregation and does not alter classification, so the same concessional rate applies. Removing butts for packing or transport is likewise a minor handling step that does not convert the leaves into a different taxable product, and the concessional GST treatment continues.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether tobacco leaves purchased from farmers after sun-curing and sold with only storage or stocking remain classifiable as tobacco leaves eligible for GST at 5%; (ii) Whether grading tobacco leaves by size, colour, length, or texture changes their tax treatment; (iii) Whether removal of butts from tobacco leaves for packing or transport changes their tax treatment.

Issue (i): Whether tobacco leaves purchased from farmers after sun-curing and sold with only storage or stocking remain classifiable as tobacco leaves eligible for GST at 5%.

Analysis: Sun-curing was treated as a drying process that removes moisture but does not alter the essential character of tobacco leaves. The relevant tariff entry distinguished tobacco leaves from unmanufactured tobacco other than tobacco leaves, and the clarification on tobacco leaves covered leaves as such, including broken leaves and stems. On the facts, storage or stocking alone did not amount to processing that would take the goods out of the concessional entry.

Conclusion: The goods continue to be tobacco leaves and are taxable at 2.5% CGST plus 2.5% SGST.

Issue (ii): Whether grading tobacco leaves by size, colour, length, or texture changes their tax treatment.

Analysis: Grading was viewed as a physical segregation based on market characteristics and not as a process that changes the identity of the leaves. Since the leaves retain their basic character after grading, the tariff classification remains unchanged.

Conclusion: Graded tobacco leaves remain eligible for the same concessional rate of 2.5% CGST plus 2.5% SGST.

Issue (iii): Whether removal of butts from tobacco leaves for packing or transport changes their tax treatment.

Analysis: Removing the butt was considered only a step to prevent damage during packing and transportation. The leaf continued to retain its character as tobacco leaf after the butts were removed, so the supply remained within the concessional entry.

Conclusion: Butt-removed tobacco leaves are still taxable at 2.5% CGST plus 2.5% SGST.

Final Conclusion: The ruling accepted that the processes described by the applicant do not convert tobacco leaves into a different taxable product, and the concessional GST treatment continues to apply.

Ratio Decidendi: A drying, grading, or minor trimming activity that does not alter the essential character of tobacco leaves does not take the goods out of the specific concessional entry for tobacco leaves.

---