Tariff classification: shaving cream qualifies for concessional GST under a specific sub item; shaving foam is excluded and taxed higher.

Tariff classification separates shaving cream and shaving foam: shaving cream, as a semi-solid emulsion requiring manual lathering, is classifiable under tariff item 33071010, while aerosol pre lathered shaving foam falls within the residual tariff item 33071090. The GST notification and amended schedules bifurcate rates within heading 3307, granting a concessional rate to specified items (shaving cream, shaving lotion, aftershave lotion) and excluding residual preparations. Outcome: shaving cream qualifies for the concessional entry, shaving foam does not and remains taxable under the residual tariff item at the higher rate.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether "Shaving Foam" and "Shaving Cream" are the same product and classifiable under HSN Code 33071010; (ii) Whether concessional GST at 5% (2.5% CGST + 2.5% SGST) applies to all products falling under HSN Code 330710 as per Notification No. 09/2025-Central Tax (Rate) dated 17.09.2025, effective from 22.09.2025.

Issue (i): Whether "Shaving Foam" and "Shaving Cream" are the same product and classifiable under HSN Code 33071010.

Analysis: The relevant tariff sub-headings under heading 3307 distinguish shaving cream as tariff item 33071010 and other pre-shave, shaving or after-shave preparations under tariff item 33071090. Composition, physical form and mode of application differ: shaving cream is a semi-solid emulsion requiring manual lathering, whereas shaving foam is an aerosol pre-lathered preparation. Chapter notes and the Customs Tariff entries show shaving cream expressly in 33071010 while other shaving preparations, including shaving foam, fall within the residual 33071090 entry. The GST schedules mirror this classification by allocating shaving cream, shaving lotion and aftershave lotion to the concessional Schedule I entry and leaving other preparations in Schedule II.

Conclusion: Shaving foam and shaving cream are not the same product for classification purposes; shaving cream is classifiable under tariff item 33071010 and shaving foam falls under tariff item 33071090.

Issue (ii): Whether concessional GST at 5% applies to all products falling under HSN Code 330710 as per Notification No. 09/2025-Central Tax (Rate) dated 17.09.2025.

Analysis: Notification entries and the amended GST schedules specifically list shaving cream, shaving lotion and aftershave lotion under the concessional schedule entry, while the residual category of pre-shave, shaving or after-shave preparations (tariff item 33071090) remains in the higher-rate schedule. The text of the notification and the schedules demonstrate a deliberate bifurcation of rates within heading 3307, treating tariff item 33071010 differently from tariff item 33071090.

Conclusion: The concessional rate does not apply to all products under HSN 330710; shaving cream, shaving lotion and aftershave lotion qualify for the concessional entry while other preparations including shaving foam (33071090) do not.

Final Conclusion: The Authority has ruled that shaving foam is distinct from shaving cream for tariff classification and that the concessional rate entry is limited to specific tariff items; consequently shaving foam is not eligible for the concessional rate and remains taxable under the residual tariff item at the higher rate.

Ratio Decidendi: Where tariff sub-headings and notified GST schedule entries separately identify specific items within a heading, classification and rate application must follow the distinct tariff itemization; goods falling within a residual sub-item are subject to the rate and treatment applicable to that residual entry rather than rates allocated to a different specific sub-item.

---