Appeal of trust u/s 12AA allowed; inter-charity donations from current income and 15% accumulation u/s 11 valid

ITAT Ahmedabad allowed the appeal of the assessee trust registered u/s 12AA for AY 2017-18. It held that the Explanation to s.11(2) only prohibits donations out of accumulated income set apart u/s 11(2) to other trusts, and does not bar inter-charity donations made from current year's income or from the permissible 15% accumulation u/s 11(1)(a). The Tribunal further held that a specific clause in the trust deed permitting inter-trust donations is not required. Donations to other registered charitable institutions were treated as valid application of income and the disallowance was deleted.

---

---

1. ISSUES PRESENTED AND CONSIDERED

1.1 Whether donation made by a charitable trust, registered under Section 12AA, to other similarly registered charitable trusts constitutes "application of income" for charitable purposes under Section 11(1)(a), notwithstanding omission in the trust deed of a specific object permitting such inter-charity donations.

1.2 Whether the restriction introduced by the Explanation to Section 11(2) regarding payment of accumulated income to other trusts affects inter-charity donations made out of current year's income or the 15% accumulation permitted under Section 11(1)(a).

2. ISSUE-WISE DETAILED ANALYSIS

Issue 1 & 2: Treatment of inter-charity donations as application of income under Section 11(1)(a) and impact of Explanation to Section 11(2)

Legal framework

2.1 The Tribunal referred to Section 11(1)(a) governing exemption of income applied for charitable purposes, Section 11(2) governing accumulation of income and its Explanation inserted by the Finance Act, 2002, and to CBDT Instruction No. 1132 dated 05.01.1978 and CBDT Circular No. 8/2002. The Tribunal also relied on the judgment of the Delhi High Court holding that donation by one registered charitable trust to another registered charitable trust constitutes application of income for charitable purposes, and that the Explanation to Section 11(2) is confined to accumulated income under that provision.

Interpretation and reasoning

2.2 The Tribunal identified the core dispute as whether the assessee's donation to six other charitable trusts, all registered under Section 12AA, qualifies as application of income under Section 11(1)(a), despite (i) deletion from the assessee's trust deed of a specific object authorising donations to other trusts, and (ii) the lower authorities' reliance on Section 11 and its Explanation to deny such application.

2.3 The Tribunal held that the Explanation to Section 11(2) only bars application of "accumulated or set apart" income covered by Section 11(2) to other trusts or institutions; if such accumulated income is paid or credited to another trust, it shall not be treated as application of income. This statutory restriction, however, does not extend to:

(a) inter-charity donations out of the income of the current year; or

(b) the accumulation up to 15% permitted under Section 11(1)(a).

2.4 Referring to CBDT Instruction No. 1132 and CBDT Circular No. 8/2002, the Tribunal noted that the Department itself has clarified that donations made by one charitable trust to another are to be treated as application of income and that the insertion of the Explanation to Section 11(2) did not alter this position with respect to current year's income governed by Section 11(1)(a).

2.5 The Tribunal emphasised that under Section 11(1)(a), the controlling test is whether the income is applied for "charitable purposes"; the statute does not mandate the presence of a specific enabling clause in the trust deed authorising each particular mode of application such as inter-trust donations. So long as the donee trusts are carrying on similar charitable activities and are duly registered under Section 12AA, donation to them constitutes application of income for charitable purposes.

2.6 The Tribunal held that the authorities below adopted an unduly technical interpretation of the trust deed. Even if the specific object clause permitting donations to other institutions had been struck off from the trust deed, such amendment cannot override or restrict the statutory benefit granted by Section 11(1)(a). A technical reading of the trust deed cannot be used to defeat a clear statutory allowance where the actual application of income is for charitable purposes recognised by the Act.

2.7 On facts, it was undisputed that the donations were made out of the current year's income and that the recipient entities were charitable trusts registered under Section 12AA and engaged in charitable activities. Hence, the inter-charity donations represented a legitimate mode of application of income under Section 11(1)(a).

Conclusions

2.8 Inter-charity donations made by a trust registered under Section 12AA to other trusts registered under Section 12AA, out of the income of the year or within the 15% accumulation under Section 11(1)(a), constitute valid application of income for charitable purposes under Section 11(1)(a), irrespective of the absence or deletion of a specific enabling object in the trust deed.

2.9 The Explanation to Section 11(2) restricts only the application of accumulated or set-apart income governed by Section 11(2) to other trusts or institutions and does not apply to application of current year's income or to the statutory 15% accumulation under Section 11(1)(a).

2.10 The disallowance of Rs. 1,17,80,300/- on the ground that the trust deed did not authorise donations to other trusts was contrary to the statutory scheme of Section 11(1)(a), the judicial precedent relied upon, and the CBDT's own circulars. The Tribunal, therefore, directed deletion of the disallowance and allowed the assessee's claim of application of income in respect of the said donation.

---