Demand of outstanding dues including taxes appeals disposed as company in liquidation cannot satisfy dues; question of law left open

Respondent company has entered liquidation and lacks funds to satisfy outstanding tax and revenue dues; the quantified tax demand is approximately Rs.2 crore. The appeals were disposed of on that factual basis, with no substantive legal determination on liability; the court expressly left the legal question open for resolution in an appropriate future case. The operative effect is termination of the present appeals without prejudice to the undecided legal issue.

---

---

The Supreme Court, in the matter involving a company under liquidation (Moser Baer India Ltd.), acknowledged that "the Official Liquidator has filed a report that the Respondent-Company ... is not financially viable and is under liquidation." The Court noted that "even if the Appellant-Revenue were to succeed, the Official Liquidator is not in a position to pay the tax amount involved," which is approximately Rs. 2 crore. Consequently, the Court disposed of the Civil Appeal "leaving the question of law open, to be decided in appropriate case," and disposed of all pending applications. The essential legal reasoning rests on the company's insolvency and inability to satisfy revenue demands, leading to dismissal without addressing substantive legal questions.

---