Kerala AAR clarifies GST supply classifications: stationery sales taxable, waste disposal under reverse charge, fines recovery exempt

The Kerala AAR ruled on various supply classifications under GST law. Supply of stationery items for consideration and disposal of waste paper/scrap as auction constituted taxable supplies under Section 7 of CGST Act, subject to reverse charge mechanism per Notification 36/2017. Supply of stationery without consideration and facilitating procurement as intermediaries without payment did not fall within supply scope. Recovery of fines/penalties from departmental staff for stationery loss was not taxable supply, while contractual penalties from suppliers required case-by-case examination. Sale of tender forms and used vehicles constituted taxable supplies. ITC reversal obligations exist per Rules 42/43 for mixed taxable/exempt supplies.

---

---

1. ISSUES PRESENTED and CONSIDERED

The core legal questions considered by the Authority for Advance Ruling (AAR) are:

- Whether various transactions undertaken by a Government stationery department constitute a 'supply' under Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017.

- If such transactions amount to supply, whether they are supply of goods or services.

- The appropriate classification, rate of tax, and valuation applicable to these supplies.

- Whether the department is entitled to avail Input Tax Credit (ITC) on all procurements of goods and services related to its activities.

- Whether the department is liable to reverse ITC availed and, if so, the manner and extent of such reversal.

- Whether the department's activities are covered under exemption notifications 2/2017-CT (goods) or 12/2017-CT (services) as amended.

2. ISSUE-WISE DETAILED ANALYSIS

Issue 1: Whether various transactions constitute 'supply' under Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017

Legal framework and precedents: Section 7(1)(a) defines 'supply' to include all forms of supply of goods or services made for a consideration in the course or furtherance of business. Section 2(17)(i) defines 'business' to include activities undertaken by government departments as public authorities. However, supplies without consideration generally do not constitute supply unless specifically covered under Schedule I. CBIC explanatory notes clarify that GST applies only to commercial transactions in the course or furtherance of business.

Court's interpretation and reasoning: The AAR examined each category of transaction:

• Supply of stationery without consideration: These are statutory supplies to other government departments without consideration. The AAR held these do not fall within 'supply' as they are not in the course or furtherance of business and are not covered under Schedule I. Hence, no GST applies.
• Supply of stationery for consideration: Supplies made against payment to entities other than government departments constitute commercial transactions and fall squarely within 'supply' under Section 7.
• Facilitating procurement as intermediaries without consideration: Such facilitation without consideration is not supply under Section 7.
• Levy of recoveries/fines/penalties for undue loss of stationery from departmental staff: These are recoveries for loss or penalties imposed under disciplinary proceedings without any supply of goods or services for consideration. The AAR held these do not amount to supply under Section 7, supported by CBIC Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST and earlier service tax precedents clarifying penalties and fines imposed for violation of law are not consideration for supply.
• Levy of recoveries/fines/penalties from suppliers as liquidated damages, EMD/SD forfeiture for breach of contract: The AAR distinguished these as recoveries pursuant to contracts. It relied on Schedule II and CBIC Circular No. 178/10/2022-GST which clarified that liquidated damages are taxable only if they arise from an agreement to tolerate or refrain from an act. Mere compensation for breach without such agreement is not taxable. Therefore, taxability depends on the specific contract terms and must be decided case-by-case.
• Repair services for stationery-related equipment: No definitive ruling was given due to lack of information on whether the service is for consideration. If for consideration, it is supply; if not, it is not supply.
• Disposal of waste paper, scrap, auction of used goods: These are supplies made for consideration in the course of business and fall within the scope of supply under Section 7. The AAR referred to Notification 36/2017-CT (Rate) and Circular No. 76/50/2018-GST clarifying such supplies by government entities to registered persons attract GST under reverse charge mechanism.
• Sale of physical tender forms: Sale against consideration ancillary to business activities is supply under Section 7.
• Sale of used motor vehicles: Sale of used vehicles by the department is supply under Section 7.

Application of law to facts: The AAR applied the definitions and CBIC clarifications to the department's activities, differentiating between supplies with and without consideration and between compensatory penalties and contractual liquidated damages.

Treatment of competing arguments: The applicant argued that supplies without consideration are statutory functions and not business activities. The AAR agreed for supplies without consideration but held that supplies for consideration are taxable. On penalties and fines, the AAR distinguished between penalties imposed for violation of law (non-supply) and contractual liquidated damages (potentially supply).

Conclusions: Supplies without consideration do not amount to supply under GST. Supplies for consideration are taxable supplies. Liquidated damages are taxable only if they arise from an independent contract to tolerate or refrain from an act. Penalties and fines imposed for breach of law or disciplinary action are not supplies.

Issue 2: Whether the supplies are goods or services

Legal framework: Section 2(52) defines 'goods' as movable property excluding money and securities; Section 2(102) defines 'services' as anything other than goods, money, and securities.

Court's reasoning: The AAR held that supplies of stationery items, waste, scrap, auctioned goods, tender forms, and used motor vehicles constitute supply of goods. Liquidated damages, EMD/SD forfeiture for breach of contract, and repair and maintenance services constitute supply of services.

Issue 3: Classification, rate of tax, and valuation

The applicant did not provide the annexure listing the specific items for classification. Hence, the AAR declined to provide any ruling on classification, rate, or valuation.

Issue 4: Entitlement to avail ITC on all procurements

Legal framework: Section 16 entitles registered persons to ITC on inputs and input services used in the course or furtherance of business, except those barred under Section 17(5). Rule 42/43 provides for apportionment and reversal of ITC where inputs are used partly for business and partly for other purposes or for exempt supplies.

Court's reasoning: The AAR held that the applicant is entitled to avail ITC on all procurements except:

• Input tax attributable exclusively to non-business purposes.
• Input tax attributable exclusively to exempt supplies.
• Input tax on goods or services barred under Section 17(5).

Therefore, ITC must be appropriately apportioned and reversed as applicable.

Issue 5: Liability to reverse ITC and manner of reversal

Legal framework: Section 17(1) and (2) and Rule 42/43 of CGST Rules govern ITC reversal where inputs are used partly for taxable and partly for exempt supplies.

Court's reasoning: Since the applicant undertakes both taxable and exempt/non-business activities, they are liable to reverse ITC attributable to exempt or non-business use. The reversal must be calculated as per the formula in Rule 42/43. The AAR declined to provide an arithmetic ruling, leaving it to the applicant to compute.

Issue 6: Applicability of exemption notifications 2/2017-CT (goods) or 12/2017-CT (services)

The applicant did not furnish an exhaustive list of activities. Hence, the AAR declined to provide a ruling on exemption applicability due to insufficient material.

3. SIGNIFICANT HOLDINGS

"Any transaction involving supply of goods or services without consideration is not a supply, barring few exceptions, in which a transaction is deemed to be a supply even without consideration."

"GST is essentially a tax only on commercial transactions. Hence, only those supplies that are in the course or furtherance of business qualify as supply under GST."

"Recovering the loss made to government or imposing fine for mistakes committed does not fall within the scope of Supply under Section 7. In order to be a supply within the meaning of this Section, goods or services or both should be supplied against a consideration."

"Where the amount paid as 'liquidated damages' is an amount paid only to compensate for injury, loss or damage suffered by the aggrieved party due to breach of the contract and there is no agreement, express or implied, by the aggrieved party receiving the liquidated damages, to refrain from or tolerate an act or to do anything for the party paying the liquidated damages, in such cases liquidated damages are mere a flow of money... Such payments do not constitute consideration for a supply and are not taxable."

"The key in such cases is to consider whether the impugned payments constitute consideration for another independent contract envisaging tolerating an act or situation or refraining from doing any act or situation or simply doing an act. If the answer is yes, then it constitutes a 'supply' within the meaning of the Act, otherwise it is not a "supply"."

"The applicant is entitled to avail ITC on all procurements of goods and services other than on the following supplies: (a) input tax attributable to inputs and input services intended exclusively for purposes other than business; (b) input tax attributable exclusively for effecting exempt supplies; (c) input tax on goods or services barred under Section 17(5)."

"Since the applicant has both taxable and exempted supplies, the applicant is liable to reverse the ITC availed by them, from 01-07-2017 onwards, as per the formula stipulated under Rule 42/43 of the CGST Rules, 2017."

---