Condonation of delay and fresh verification of TDS records led to remand for re-adjudication.

Delay in filing the first appeal was condoned where the appeal had been dismissed in limine and the assessee showed that quarterly TDS returns, challans and party-wise statements had not been properly appreciated. Applying the interest of substantial justice, the matter was remitted for fresh verification so the supporting records could be produced and examined in consequential proceedings. The operative effect was a fresh adjudication after document-based verification rather than rejection on limitation grounds.

---

---

Issues: Whether the delay in filing the first appeal deserved condonation and whether the matter required remand for fresh verification in view of the assessee's claim that relevant TDS records and returns were not properly appreciated.

Analysis: The appeal before the first appellate authority had been dismissed in limine without condoning a delay of 181 days. The record also showed that the assessment was framed without proper appreciation of the quarterly TDS returns, challans and party-wise statements relied upon by the assessee. In these circumstances, and keeping in view the interest of substantial justice, the delay was condoned and the dispute was sent back for fresh verification so that the assessee could produce the supporting documents in consequential proceedings.

Conclusion: The delay was condoned and the matter was remitted to the Assessing Officer for fresh adjudication after verification of the relevant documents.

---