Refunds of voluntarily deposited CVD and SAD after failed export obligations governed by Section 142(3) read with 142(6)(a)

The HC held that refund claims for CVD and SAD voluntarily deposited after failing export obligations cannot be denied by reliance on section 142(8)(a); instead they fall under section 142(3) read with 142(6)(a) and must be processed under the Central Excise Act and Cenvat Credit Rules as applicable at the time of import. The order rejecting the refund claim was quashed and set aside, and the matter remanded to respondent authorities to adjudicate the refund on merits under the stated statutory provisions. The petition was partly allowed by way of remand.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether rejection of Form TRAN-1 filed by the petitioners for carrying forward transitional credit was lawful; (ii) Whether the order-in-original dated 10.10.2019 rejecting the petitioners' refund claim of duties (CVD and SAD) paid for non-fulfilment of export obligations was sustainable.

Issue (i): Lawfulness of rejection of Form TRAN-1 filed for carrying forward transitional credit.

Analysis: The petitioners had imported goods in 2016 without payment of duty under Advance Authorisation and EPCG schemes and later, in 2018 (after 01.07.2017), voluntarily deposited duties including CVD and SAD on account of shortfall in export obligations. At the appointed day (30.06.2017) the petitioners did not have an outstanding balance of such duties reflected as credit in the Cenvat Register. Section 140 of the CGST Act governs carry forward of transitional credit and requires that the balance to be carried forward exist as on the appointed day. The court examined the timing of payment and the absence of admissible credit as on 30.06.2017 and considered the verification report relied upon by the authorities.

Conclusion: The rejection of Form TRAN-1 is sustained as the petitioners did not possess an admissible outstanding credit on the appointed day; this disposes the challenge to the TRAN-1 rejection against the petitioners.

Issue (ii): Validity of order-in-original dated 10.10.2019 rejecting refund claim of CVD and SAD voluntarily deposited by the petitioners.

Analysis: Section 142 of the CGST Act contains transitional provisions. Section 142(3) mandates that every claim for refund of any amount of CENVAT credit, duty, tax, interest or any other amount paid under the existing law shall be disposed of in accordance with the provisions of the existing law and amounts eventually accruing shall be paid in cash. The court distinguished deposits made voluntarily (not in recovery proceedings) from amounts recovered as arrears under section 142(8)(a). Reliance was placed on relevant judicial decisions applying section 142(3) and 142(6)(a), which held that voluntarily deposited CVD/SAD arising from non-fulfilment of export obligations are to be processed under the pre-GST law (Central Excise Act and Cenvat Credit Rules) and may be refunded in cash where admissible.

Conclusion: The order-in-original dated 10.10.2019 rejecting the refund claim is quashed and set aside. The refund claim is to be remanded to the respondent authorities for fresh decision on merits under the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004 (in accordance with section 142(3) read with section 142(6)(a) of the CGST Act, 2017); if found eligible, refund shall be paid in cash.

Final Conclusion: The petition is partly allowed the TRAN-1 rejection is left undisturbed while the refund rejection is quashed and remanded for fresh adjudication under the pre-GST law, with direction to complete the exercise within twelve weeks after receipt of the order copy.

Ratio Decidendi: Where duties (including CVD and SAD) were voluntarily deposited after the appointed day in respect of imports made prior to the appointed day, claims for refund of such amounts fall to be processed under the existing (pre-GST) law pursuant to section 142(3) read with section 142(6)(a) of the CGST Act, 2017, and amounts found admissible are payable in cash; section 142(8)(a) applies only to amounts recoverable in recovery proceedings and is not applicable to voluntary deposits.

---