Treaty treatment of rights entitlements under India-Ireland DTAA placed gains in the residence state, excluding Indian tax.

Gains from sale of rights entitlements under the India-Ireland DTAA were treated as gains from alienation of property, not as gains from shares, because a rights entitlement is a distinct and separately exercisable asset under the Companies Act and market practice. On that reading, Article 13(6) applied residually, so the gain was taxable only in the State of residence and not in India. The tribunal also held that, once the treaty excluded the gain from Indian taxation, capital loss on share sales could not be set off against those exempt rights-entitlement gains in computing Indian taxable income.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether gains from sale of rights entitlements are taxable in India under Article 13(5) of the India-Ireland DTAA or are covered by Article 13(6) as gains from alienation of property taxable only in the State of residence. (ii) Whether capital loss on sale of shares can be set off against such gains from sale of rights entitlements while computing Indian taxable income.

Issue (i): Whether gains from sale of rights entitlements are taxable in India under Article 13(5) of the India-Ireland DTAA or are covered by Article 13(6) as gains from alienation of property taxable only in the State of residence.

Analysis: Rights entitlements were held to be distinct from equity shares. Section 62 of the Companies Act, 2013 recognizes a shareholder's right to subscribe, renounce, or transfer the offer, which shows that the entitlement is a separate and exercisable right and not a share itself. The statutory and market treatment of rights entitlements also supported this distinction, including separate ISINs and treatment as an option in securities. The treaty text was read strictly: Article 13(5) refers to shares, while Article 13(6) applies residually to property not covered by paragraphs 1 to 5. Since rights entitlements are neither shares nor comparable interests covered by Article 13(5), the residuary article applied.

Conclusion: The gain from sale of rights entitlements falls under Article 13(6) and is taxable only in Ireland, not in India.

Issue (ii): Whether capital loss on sale of shares can be set off against such gains from sale of rights entitlements while computing Indian taxable income.

Analysis: Once the gain on rights entitlements was found to be outside Indian taxing under Article 13(6), the computation provisions of the Act could not be used to bring that exempt gain into the Indian tax base by setting off losses taxable under Article 13(5). The tribunal followed the principle that where treaty benefits exclude the gain from Indian taxation, the corresponding source-country computation and set-off exercise does not arise for that gain.

Conclusion: The capital loss on shares could not be set off against the treaty-exempt gains from rights entitlements.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded on the substantive tax issue, and the rights entitlements were held to be taxable only in the assessee's State of residence, with the loss set-off adjustment rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: A right entitlement arising from a rights issue is a separate asset from shares and, unless specifically covered by the share-based charging articles of the treaty, falls within the residuary capital gains article taxable only in the State of residence.

---