Free-of-cost design and drawing specifications excluded from excise assessable value absent additional consideration for sale
Free-of-cost design, drawings and specifications supplied by a buyer to vendors were held not to form part of the assessable value under Central Excise valuation where they served as manufacturing specifications rather than additional consideration for the sale. The analysis distinguished mere layout or dimensional requirements from separately chargeable engineering input, and concluded that only consideration flowing from the buyer to the manufacturer in connection with the sale can be added to assessable value. On that basis, the notional value of the supplied material was excluded, the valuation demand failed, and the impugned order was set aside.
Issues: Whether the notional cost of design, drawings and specifications supplied free of cost by the buyer to the vendors was includible in the assessable value of parts and components manufactured and cleared under the Central Excise valuation scheme.
Analysis: The valuation provisions were considered to determine whether the free supply of design and drawing material amounted to additional consideration for the sale of goods. The reasoning adopted was that only consideration flowing from the buyer to the manufacturer in connection with the sale can be added to the assessable value, and that drawings and designs supplied as specifications for manufacture, before or in the course of vendor selection, do not by themselves constitute such additional consideration. The distinction between mere specifications and detailed engineering drawings was also recognised, and the supplied material was treated as layout or dimensional requirements necessary for the desired parts rather than a separately chargeable input forming part of the sale price.
Conclusion: The notional value of the free design and drawings was not includible in the assessable value, and the demand based on such inclusion could not stand.
Final Conclusion: The impugned valuation order was set aside and the appeals succeeded.
Ratio Decidendi: Free-of-cost specifications, drawings and designs supplied by the buyer do not constitute additional consideration for sale unless they are shown to form part of the price or to be expenses incurred on behalf of the manufacturer in the legally relevant sense for excise valuation.
TaxTMI 
AI Drafter ✕
TaxTMI 
