CESTAT allows appeal, drops service tax liability for exporter under Business Support Service category and CENVAT credit on club fees

CESTAT Kolkata allowed the appeal, setting aside the impugned order. The tribunal held that the appellant was not liable for service tax under Business Support Service category as it exported its own goods, not providing support services to another entity. CENVAT credit on club membership renewal fees was allowed as fees were for corporate meetings with stakeholders for sales promotion. Penalty was dropped since tax was paid before show cause notice issuance. The demand for period 2011-12 was also barred by limitation as show cause notice was issued beyond prescribed time limit.

---

---

Issues Involved:

1. Demand of Service Tax under the category of "Business Support Service".
2. Denial of CENVAT Credit on club membership renewal fees.
3. Suo-moto recredit to the CENVAT account without documentary evidence.
4. Imposition of penalty for non-payment of Service Tax under "Intellectual Property Service other than copyright".

Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:

Issue No. 1: Demand of Service Tax under "Business Support Service"

The appellant challenged the demand of Service Tax amounting to Rs. 1,54,77,549/- under the category of "Business Support Service". The Revenue alleged that the appellant provided business support services to its group company by exporting its own goods, thereby saving customs duty under the EPCG Scheme. However, it was held that the appellant's arrangement with its group company was not a service but a mutual understanding to optimize customs duty savings. The tribunal found that the appellant did not outsource any service to its group company and that the arrangement did not constitute a service under the definition of "Business Support Service". The tribunal relied on the C.B.E.C. Circular No. 334/4/2006-TRU dated 28.02.2006, which clarified that an element of outsourcing must be present for a transaction to be taxable under this category. Consequently, the demand under "Business Support Service" was dropped.

Issue No. 2: Denial of CENVAT Credit on Club Membership Renewal Fees

The appellant was denied CENVAT Credit of Rs. 82,400/- on club membership renewal fees, which was contested on the grounds that the club membership was used for business purposes. The tribunal noted that the membership was used for organizing meetings with stakeholders, which qualifies as a business activity. Citing the case of Reliance Industries Limited, the tribunal held that CENVAT Credit is allowable when such services are used for business purposes. Therefore, the denial of CENVAT Credit on club membership renewal fees was overturned.

Issue No. 3: Suo-moto Recredit to the CENVAT Account

The appellant took a suo-moto recredit of Rs. 1,06,839/- in the CENVAT account, which was disputed due to the lack of documentary evidence. The tribunal observed that the recredit was due to service tax being paid twice or in excess and noted that the issue was not raised during periodic audits. The tribunal found that the Show Cause Notice was barred by limitation as it was issued beyond the permissible period. Consequently, the demand was set aside on the grounds of limitation.

Issue No. 4: Imposition of Penalty for Non-payment of Service Tax

A penalty of Rs. 1,49,822/- was imposed for non-payment of Service Tax under "Intellectual Property Service other than copyright". The appellant had already paid the tax along with interest before the issuance of the Show Cause Notice. The tribunal held that since the tax was paid prior to the notice, no penalty was imposable, and thus, the penalty was dropped.

Limitation:

The tribunal noted that periodic audits were conducted, and the details were available in the public domain. It was held that the Show Cause Notice issued on 15.12.2016 for the period 2011-12 was barred by limitation, supporting the appellant's case on this ground as well.

Conclusion:

The tribunal set aside the impugned order, allowing the appeal with consequential relief. The demands under "Business Support Service" were dropped, CENVAT Credit on club membership fees was allowed, the suo-moto recredit was upheld, and the penalty for non-payment of Service Tax was removed.

---