2024 (10) TMI 910 - AT - Customs

Red Sanders export scheme busted through mis-declared baggage and fake airway bills, penalties confirmed under sections 114 and 114AA

Shri Mayank Gupta, Director of M/s Sky Barge Freight Pvt. Ltd., Shri Ravindra Kumar, Proprietor of M/s Vin Global Logistics Versus Commissioner of Customs (Export) And Commissioner of Customs, ACC Export Commissionerate, New Customs House, New Delhi Versus Shri Krishna Chandra Jha, Shri Ravindra Kumar, Proprietor of M/s Vin Global Logistics, Shri Mayank Gupta, Shri Sarvesh Kumar, Director of M/s FSD Cargo Movers

Shri Mayank Gupta, Director of M/s Sky Barge Freight Pvt. Ltd., Shri Ravindra Kumar, Proprietor of M/s Vin Global Logistics Versus Commissioner of Customs ... Issues Involved:1. Confiscation of Red Sanders and imposition of penalties under sections 114 and 114AA of the Customs Act, 1962.2. Non-imposition of penalties under section 114AA on certain individuals.3. Appeals by individuals against penalties imposed under section 114.Detailed Analysis:1. Confiscation and Imposition of Penalties:The Commissioner of Customs confiscated 1103.1 kg of Red Sanders under sections 113(d) and 113(h)(i) of the Customs Act, 1962, and imposed penalties on seven individuals. The confiscation was due to an attempt to export the Red Sanders, a prohibited item, by misdeclaring it as household goods. The penalties varied among the individuals, with the highest being Rs. 75,00,000/- imposed on Shri Prashant Kumar Jha under section 114AA.2. Non-Imposition of Penalties under Section 114AA:The Revenue filed appeals against the non-imposition of penalties under section 114AA on Shri Krishna Chandra Jha, Shri Ravindra Kumar, Shri Mayank Gupta, and Shri Sarvesh Kumar. Section 114AA mandates penalties for the use of false or incorrect material with knowledge. The Revenue argued that these individuals played significant roles in using false documents without verifying their authenticity, thus warranting penalties under section 114AA.- Shri Mayank Gupta: The Tribunal found no error in the Commissioner's decision not to impose a penalty under section 114AA, as the airway bill, a document required by airlines and not filed under the Customs Act, was not considered a document for the purposes of the Act.- Shri Ravindra Kumar: Similar to Shri Mayank Gupta, the Tribunal upheld the Commissioner's decision, noting that the airway bill was not a document filed under the Act, and thus, section 114AA penalties were not applicable.- Shri Sarvesh Kumar: The Tribunal found that Shri Sarvesh Kumar, as a customs broker, was liable under section 114AA due to mis-declarations in the baggage declaration, a document filed under the Customs Act. The Tribunal imposed a penalty of Rs. 75,00,000/- under section 114AA.- Shri Krishna Chandra Jha: The Tribunal imposed a penalty of Rs. 50,00,000/- under section 114AA, concluding that Shri Krishna Chandra Jha had knowledge of the fraud and played a significant role in the conspiracy.3. Appeals Against Penalties under Section 114:- Shri Mayank Gupta: His appeal against the penalty under section 114 was dismissed. The Tribunal found that his actions contributed to the goods being liable for confiscation, thus justifying the penalty.- Shri Ravindra Kumar: His appeal was also dismissed. The Tribunal determined that his involvement in arranging fake airway bills was crucial to the attempted export, validating the penalty under section 114.Conclusion:The appeals were disposed of with modifications to the penalties as follows:- Appeals by Shri Mayank Gupta and Shri Ravindra Kumar against penalties under section 114 were dismissed.- Revenue's appeals seeking penalties under section 114AA on Shri Sarvesh Kumar and Shri Krishna Chandra Jha were allowed, with penalties imposed accordingly.- Revenue's appeals against non-imposition of penalties under section 114AA on Shri Mayank Gupta and Shri Ravindra Kumar were dismissed.The Tribunal's decision emphasized the importance of verifying the authenticity of documents and the roles individuals play in facilitating illegal exports.