GST Registration Cancellation Overturned: Procedural Errors Invalidate Original Order, Ensuring Fair Hearing for Petitioner

HC ruled on GST registration cancellation, finding procedural irregularities in the original order. The court modified the cancellation date to 24.05.2022, ensuring the petitioner was not unfairly penalized retrospectively. Respondents retained the right to pursue legal actions for statutory violations, while addressing the lack of fair opportunity to respond to the show cause notice.

---

---

Issues:
1. Modification of GST registration cancellation order
2. Non-compliance with GST Act and Rules
3. Lack of opportunity to respond to cancellation reasons
4. Appeal rejection on limitation ground
5. Cancellation of GST registration with retrospective effect

Analysis:

The petitioner sought modification of the order cancelling its GST registration with retrospective effect. The petitioner had stopped business operations in March 2022 and had requested cancellation of GST registration through its Chartered Accountant. However, a Show Cause Notice (SCN) was issued on 24.05.2022, citing non-compliance with GST Act provisions as the reason for cancellation. The petitioner's registration was suspended from the date of the SCN, and subsequently cancelled due to failure to respond to the SCN. The reasons for cancellation in the impugned order differed from those in the SCN, and the petitioner's appeal against the cancellation was rejected on the ground of being time-barred.

The Court noted that the petitioner was not contesting the cancellation itself but objected to the retrospective effect of the cancellation. The Court found that the petitioner was not given a fair opportunity to respond to the reasons stated in the impugned order, which were different from those in the SCN. The respondents, during the proceedings, agreed to make the cancellation of GST registration effective from the date of the SCN, i.e., 24.05.2022, instead of the original retrospective date.

Consequently, the Court disposed of the petition by directing the cancellation of GST registration from 24.05.2022, clarifying that the modification applied only to the retrospective aspect. The order emphasized that the modification did not prevent the respondents from taking further legal action for statutory violations or dues recovery in accordance with the law.

Overall, the judgment addressed the procedural irregularities in the cancellation of GST registration, ensuring that the petitioner's rights were upheld by modifying the order to prevent retrospective effects and by allowing the respondents to pursue legal actions within the bounds of the law.

---