Recovery certificate as fresh cause of action upheld for insolvency admission against a corporate guarantor despite pending review

A final recovery certificate or money decree constitutes a fresh cause of action for initiating Section 7 insolvency proceedings against a corporate guarantor under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, and pending review proceedings before the DRT do not dilute that effect. The allegation that the corporate debtor has only one asset and that CIRP may not be fruitful does not, by itself, defeat admission once debt and default are established. On that basis, the challenge to the admission order failed and the insolvency proceedings were upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the admission of the Section 7 application against the corporate guarantor could be interfered with on the grounds that the recovery certificate was under challenge, the review proceedings were pending, and the corporate debtor had only one asset.

Analysis: The corporate debtor had stood as guarantor for the financial facilities granted to the principal borrower, and a recovery certificate had already been issued after adjudication of the creditor's claim. The subsequent invocation of the corporate guarantee and filing of the Section 7 application were based on the continuing non-payment of the dues. A recovery certificate or money decree gives rise to a fresh cause of action for proceedings under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code. The pendency of a review before the Debt Recovery Tribunal did not dilute the effect of the recovery certificate for the purpose of insolvency admission. The argument that the corporate debtor had only one asset and that CIRP would not be fruitful did not furnish a ground to set aside an otherwise valid admission order once debt and default were established.

Conclusion: The challenge to the admission of the Section 7 application failed, and the order admitting insolvency proceedings against the corporate guarantor was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: A final recovery certificate or money decree constitutes a fresh cause of action for initiating proceedings under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, and the pendency of collateral review proceedings or the alleged inadequacy of assets does not, by itself, defeat admission once debt and default are proved.

---