Legal Challenge Succeeds: GST Annual Return Remanded for Fresh Review, Covid-19 Context Considered in Tax Discrepancy Case

HC allowed appeal challenging adjudication order, remanding case back to authority. Court directed reconsideration of GSTR-9 annual return filed for 2017-18, noting Covid-19 extended filing period and revenue-neutral nature of tax discrepancy. Appellant's unintentional error was to be examined afresh without treating the order as precedent.

---

---

Issues involved: Challenge to adjudication order, consideration of annual return filed in GSTR-9 for financial year 2017-18.

Adjudication Order Challenge: The appellant challenged the order rejecting the challenge to the adjudication order, directing them to avail the statutory appellate remedy. The High Court heard submissions from both parties and considered whether the annual return filed in GSTR-9 for the financial year 2017-18 could be ignored.

Annual Return Consideration: The appellant had initially clarified certain discrepancies in their returns to the concerned officer. They later brought to the department's attention missed output GST liability and equivalent Input tax credit of Cess for the relevant period, correcting the error in their GSTR-9 filing. The appellant emphasized that the error was unintentional, with no intent to evade tax, and that it was revenue neutral.

Court's Decision: The Court noted the importance of considering the GSTR-9 filed within the extended period due to Covid-19 notifications, to prevent prejudice to the assessee's rights. Additionally, the Court acknowledged the appellant's argument that the matter was revenue neutral. Consequently, the Court remanded the matter back to the adjudicating authority for a fresh decision, emphasizing that the order should not be treated as a precedent.

Conclusion: The appeal and connected application were disposed of with no costs, and the Court directed the adjudicating authority to reconsider the submissions, provide a personal hearing, examine the GSTR-9 annual return, and make a fresh decision in accordance with the law.

---