Classification of phenol formaldehyde aqueous solution: low-resin content kept it outside synthetic resin tariff coverage.

An aqueous solution of phenol formaldehyde containing less than 45% solid resin was treated as an intermediary product and not as a finished synthetic resin. On that basis, and in line with the Delhi High Court view that such a liquid solution is not artificial or synthetic resin in liquid form, it was held not to answer Tariff Item 15A under the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944. The stated ratio is that an aqueous solution with less than 45% solid resin is not classifiable as artificial or synthetic resin under Tariff Item 15A.

---

---

Issues: Whether the aqueous solution of phenol formaldehyde manufactured by the appellants, containing less than 45% solid resin, fell under Tariff Item 15A of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944.

Analysis: The product was an aqueous solution with resin content below 45% and was treated as an intermediary product rather than a finished synthetic resin. The prior decision of the Delhi High Court had already held that such a solution could not be regarded as artificial or synthetic resin in liquid form and, therefore, did not answer Tariff Item 15A.

Conclusion: The product did not fall under Tariff Item 15A.

Ratio Decidendi: An aqueous solution containing less than 45% solid resin is not classifiable as artificial or synthetic resin under Tariff Item 15A.

---