Tariff classification of steel pattis turned on whether straight-length goods could count as strips without coiling.

Steel products described as pattis or pattas were discussed for tariff classification under the Central Excise Tariff. The tariff meaning of "strips" was read as covering hot or cold rolled rectangular products supplied in coil or flattened coil form, with straight length treated only as an incidental feature of flattened coils. Because the goods were short straight lengths, never coiled, and were recognised as pattis in a departmental exemption notification, the authorities erred in classifying them as strips merely on dimensional resemblance. However, the record lacked essential measurements, especially width, so the goods could not be finally classified on the existing material and required fresh determination with full dimensional details.

---

---

Issues: Whether the steel products known as pattis or pattas were classifiable as strips under Item 25(12) of the Central Excise Tariff or as pieces roughly shaped by rolling or forging of iron or steel under Item 25(8), and whether the absence of coiling and the short straight length of the goods excluded them from classification as strips.

Analysis: The definition of strips in the tariff contemplated hot or cold rolled products in rectangular cross-section, supplied in coil or flattened coil form, with the reference to straight length being only an accompanying qualification of flattened coil form and not an independent description. The products in question were accepted to be short straight lengths, never subjected to coiling, and were recognised as pattis by the departmental exemption notification. The adjudicating authorities erred in treating straight length goods as strips merely because their dimensions might otherwise resemble strip products. At the same time, the record lacked the necessary measurements, especially width, to determine the true shape and proportional surface characteristics of the goods for proper classification.

Conclusion: The goods could not be finally classified as strips on the existing record, and the matter had to be sent back for fresh determination with full dimensional details.

---