Tariff classification of industrial scrap depends on essential character and market identity, not eventual melting use.

Industrial scrap made up of cuttings of rails, billets, plates, axles and channels was treated as iron and steel products under Tariff Item 26AA because tariff classification depended on the goods' essential character and market identity, not on the label "scrap" alone. The tribunal noted that cut or rejected steel articles may retain their original class if they are merely reduced in size and remain recognisable as industrial scrap, and their later use for melting does not by itself change the tariff heading. The notice was also held adequate despite not expressly citing Tariff Item 26AA, because the material facts were disclosed and no prejudice was shown. The departmental classification was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether industrial scrap consisting of cuttings of rails, billets, plates, axles and channels was correctly classified under Tariff Item 26AA as iron and steel products rather than as melting scrap.

Analysis: The nature of the goods had to be determined on the totality of circumstances and not by the label of "scrap" alone. Scrap in the steel industry may include rejected, cut or trimmed products, and the record showed that the disputed goods were cut pieces of rails, billets, plates, axles and channels of limited length. The price circular distinguished industrial scrap from melting scrap, and the goods were shown to possess the characteristics of industrial scrap capable of being treated as products of lesser dimensions. The fact that they were ultimately used for melting did not alter their basic identity for tariff purposes. The non-mention of Tariff Item 26AA in the notice was not fatal, since the notice disclosed the material facts and the assessees were not misled. The earlier identical decision and the provisional assessment arrangement also supported the departmental classification.

Conclusion: The classification under Tariff Item 26AA was upheld and the challenge by the assessee failed.

Ratio Decidendi: For tariff classification, a cut or rejected article may remain a product of the original class if its essential character and market identity are that of a steel product, and its eventual use as melting scrap does not by itself determine the tariff heading.

---