Retail-sale valuation must follow Rule 6(a) where goods are sold directly to users and no wholesale price exists.

Where goods were sold directly to users for their own consumption, the transactions were retail sales and quantity alone did not convert them into wholesale sales. On that factual basis, no wholesale price was available for valuation under Section 4(1)(a), and the department could not shift to an alleged wholesale basis inconsistent with the show cause notice. Valuation therefore had to proceed on the retail-sale basis under Rule 6(a). The order adopting a wholesale-price approach was set aside, and the departmental review challenge and appeal failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee's clearances were retail sales only and, if so, whether the assessable value had to be determined under Rule 6(a) of the Central Excises (Valuation) Rules instead of on the basis of an alleged wholesale price under Section 4(1)(a) of the Central Excises and Salt Act.

Analysis: The valuation basis adopted in the show cause notice proceeded on the footing that the sales were retail sales and that a deemed wholesale price had to be arrived at by allowing a reasonable abatement under Rule 6(a). The later finding that wholesale sales existed was inconsistent with that basis and was beyond jurisdiction. The material on record showed that the goods were sold directly to users for their own consumption, and quantity alone did not convert such transactions into wholesale sales. On that footing, there was no wholesale price available for application under Section 4(1)(a).

Conclusion: The assessee's sales were retail sales only, and the assessable value could not be determined on the footing of an available wholesale price under Section 4(1)(a); the departmental review challenge failed.

Final Conclusion: The valuation had to proceed on the retail-sale basis contemplated by Rule 6(a), and the order holding otherwise was rightly set aside, resulting in dismissal of the review notice and the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: Where an assessee sells goods only in retail to direct users, the proper officer cannot abandon that basis and invoke an alleged wholesale price under Section 4(1)(a); valuation must be determined under the rule governing retail sales.

---