Valuation norms for small scale exemption support exclusion of transport and erection charges from plant and machinery cost.

A concessional exemption for small scale units under the 3-2-1981 notification was applied by reference to the settled 1975 governmental norms for valuing plant and machinery. Those norms excluded transport charges and erection charges, and the Tribunal held that the same valuation basis governed the exemption question. On that approach, the unit's plant and machinery fell below the prescribed ceiling of Rs. 20 lakhs once the disputed elements were excluded, so the exemption was available. The record already contained the necessary figures, making remand unnecessary. The departmental challenge therefore failed and the exemption order was sustained.

---

---

Issues: Whether the respondents were entitled to exemption from cess under the notification dated 3-2-1981 on the basis that the value of plant and machinery in their unit did not exceed Rs. 20 lakhs after excluding transport charges, erection charges and the cost of other materials.

Analysis: The levy was a cess imposed as duty of excise under Section 9 of the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951, and the exemption notification had to be applied on a consistent basis. The Government had already fixed norms in 1975 for determining the value of plant and machinery for distinguishing small scale units from larger units. Those norms excluded transport and erection charges, and the Tribunal found no reason to depart from them while interpreting the concessional notification. As the record already contained all necessary data, remand was unnecessary. On exclusion of any one of the disputed elements, the original value worked out below the prescribed ceiling of Rs. 20 lakhs.

Conclusion: The respondents were eligible for the exemption and the appeal failed.

Final Conclusion: The impugned order granting exemption was sustained and the departmental challenge was rejected, with consequential relief following for the respondents.

Ratio Decidendi: A concessional exemption for small scale units must be construed by applying the settled governmental norms for valuation of plant and machinery, including the exclusion of transport and erection charges where those norms govern the field.

---