Capital gains on partnership retirement proceeds where the deed assigned and relinquished rights in firm assets

A retirement deed that expressly recorded assignment and relinquishment of all rights in partnership assets in favour of continuing partners for lump sum consideration was treated as a transfer within the capital gains provisions. On those facts, the amount received on retirement was held taxable as long-term capital gains. Authorities dealing with a simple valuation-based retirement as mere realisation of pre-existing rights were distinguished because the decisive factor was the specific mode of retirement and the contractual extinguishment of rights.

---

---

Issues: Whether the amount received by the assessee on retirement from the firm was chargeable as long-term capital gains on the footing that the retirement deed involved a transfer of the assessee's rights in the partnership assets.

Analysis: The amount received on retirement was held to be taxable in capital gains because the retirement deed specifically recorded that the assessee had assigned and relinquished all rights in the firm's assets in favour of the continuing partners for a lump sum consideration. The earlier authorities on retirement and dissolution were examined, but the decisive factor was the mode of retirement. On the facts found, the transaction answered the statutory concept of transfer within the meaning of the capital gains provisions, and the reliance placed on decisions treating a simple valuation-based retirement as a mere realisation of pre-existing rights was held not to govern the present case.

Conclusion: The amount received by the assessee on retirement was correctly assessed as long-term capital gains, and the addition was upheld against the assessee.

---