Commercial appraisal of profits governs dividend non-declaration under section 23A, with investment losses a relevant factor.

Section 23A requires a commercial appraisal of a company's financial position when assessing whether dividend non-declaration is justified for smallness of profits. The Income-tax Officer is to act on the standpoint of a prudent businessman or director, and the statutory factors are not exhaustive. Balance-sheet figures are not conclusive where cogent material shows that they do not reflect the true financial position. On the facts discussed, the assessed profit was small relative to capital, and the fall in the value of investments was a relevant circumstance in deciding whether dividend distribution was reasonable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the non-declaration of dividend was justified on the ground of smallness of profits for the purposes of section 23A, and whether the fall in the value of investments could be taken into account in deciding the reasonableness of dividend distribution.

Analysis: Section 23A requires the Income-tax Officer to judge the reasonableness of dividend declaration on an overall view of the company's financial position, acting as a prudent businessman or prudent director, and not by treating the statutory factors as exhaustive. The expression "smallness of profits" is to be understood in commercial terms, and the balance-sheet is not conclusive if cogent material shows that particular items were inflated or deflated. On the facts, the assessed profit was small in relation to the company's capital, and the depreciation in value of investments was a relevant circumstance bearing on whether any dividend ought reasonably to have been declared.

Conclusion: The non-declaration of dividend was justified, and the Tribunal was right in treating the fall in the value of investments as a relevant circumstance; the question was answered in the affirmative in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: In applying section 23A, reasonableness of dividend distribution must be determined on a commercial appraisal of all relevant circumstances from the standpoint of a prudent businessman, and the balance-sheet figures are not conclusive where cogent evidence shows they do not reflect the true financial position.

---