1980 (9) TMI 145 - AT - Income Tax

Conversion of business to partnership deemed gift due to profit sharing transfer. Gift valuation recalculated lower.

The Tribunal held that the conversion of a proprietary business into a partnership constituted a gift, based on the transfer of the right to share profits ... - Issues:1. Whether the conversion of proprietary business into a partnership constitutes a gift.2. Whether the transfer of property was without consideration.3. Valuation of the gift for tax purposes.Issue 1: Conversion of proprietary business into partnership - Gift or notThe appeal was against the order confirming the assessment made on the assessee for converting his sole proprietorship business into a partnership. The contention was that this conversion did not involve a gift. The GTO determined the value of the gift as Rs. 85,520, considering the transfer of 90% of the right to share profits without consideration. The assessee argued that the capital contribution and agreement to bear losses by other partners constituted consideration, relying on relevant case laws. The Tribunal noted that the transaction involved the grant of partnership in property, constituting a transfer. It held that the conversion amounted to a gift, as per the decision in CGT vs. V.A.H. Ayya Nadar.Issue 2: Transfer of property without considerationThe question was whether the transfer of the proprietary business into a partnership was without consideration. The assessee argued that the capital contribution and agreement to bear losses by other partners constituted consideration. The Tribunal referred to a case where the transfer was deemed to have consideration due to capital contribution and service rendered. In this case, the partners contributed only Rs. 101 each, while the bulk of the capital was contributed by the assessee. The Tribunal found the capital contribution by other partners illusory, with no prior experience in the business, leading to the conclusion that the transaction amounted to a gift.Issue 3: Valuation of the giftThe GTO valued the gift at Rs. 85,520, considering average profits, interest on capital, and managerial remuneration. The assessee argued for higher interest and remuneration rates. The Tribunal agreed with the assessee's contentions and recalculated the value of the gift at Rs. 53,877, considering a higher interest rate and managerial remuneration. The appeal was allowed in part, modifying the assessment to reflect the revised taxable gift amount.This detailed analysis of the judgment highlights the issues surrounding the conversion of a proprietary business into a partnership, the consideration involved in such transfers, and the valuation of gifts for tax purposes as determined by the Tribunal.