Book-entry money gifts without actual transfer are invalid for wealth-tax purposes; later statutory change applies only prospectively.

Money gifts recorded only by book entries in the assessee's proprietary accounts were held invalid where there was no actual delivery to the donees and the cash balance on the relevant dates was insufficient to support the purported transfers; the amounts therefore remained includible in net wealth. The later provision treating gifts of money by book entries as taxable under wealth-tax law applied only from 1 April 1976, so gifts made in 1969 and 1970 fell outside its scope. The Revenue succeeded on validity of the gifts, while the earlier gifts could not be governed by the later-enacted provision.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether gifts of money made only by book entries in the assessee's own business accounts, without delivery of cash and without sufficient cash balance on the relevant dates, were valid gifts so as to exclude the amounts from net wealth; (ii) whether section 4(5A) of the Wealth-tax Act applied to gifts made before 1 April 1976.

Issue (i): whether gifts of money made only by book entries in the assessee's own business accounts, without delivery of cash and without sufficient cash balance on the relevant dates, were valid gifts so as to exclude the amounts from net wealth.

Analysis: The gifts were found to be mere book entries in the assessee's proprietary books, with no actual delivery to the donees and with cash balances on the relevant dates lower than the amounts purportedly gifted. A valid gift required a transfer of existing property and, on the facts, the amounts of Rs. 12,000 each were not available as such on the respective dates. The fact that gift-tax assessments had been made did not by itself establish that the transfers were legally valid or chargeable to gift-tax for wealth-tax purposes.

Conclusion: The gifts were not valid and the amounts were rightly includible in the assessee's net wealth; the issue is decided against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue.

Issue (ii): whether section 4(5A) of the Wealth-tax Act applied to gifts made before 1 April 1976.

Analysis: The provision dealing with gifts of money by entries in books of account came into force only from 1 April 1976 and, on its plain terms, governed gifts made from that date onwards. Gifts made in 1969 and 1970 could not be brought within that provision.

Conclusion: Section 4(5A) did not apply to the impugned gifts made before 1 April 1976; this issue is decided in favour of the assessee on the point of applicability, though it does not alter the final result.

Final Conclusion: The Revenue succeeded because the alleged gifts were held to be invalid on the facts, and the corresponding amounts were restored to the assessee's wealth-tax assessments.

Ratio Decidendi: A money gift is not valid for wealth-tax purposes unless there is a transfer of existing property in law; mere book entries without actual availability of the amount and without delivery or acceptance cannot constitute a valid gift, and a later-enacted provision cannot govern gifts made before its commencement.

---