Section 80T deduction requires taxable capital gains and cannot be used to enlarge carried-forward loss

Deduction under section 80T was confined to taxable capital gains forming part of gross total income. Where capital gains were first adjusted against business loss under section 71(2), no taxable capital gains remained, so the deduction could not be claimed. The provision was treated as an abatement of taxable capital gains rather than a step in computing capital gains. On that basis, the assessee could not use section 80T to create or enlarge a carried-forward loss.

---

---

Issues: Whether deduction under section 80T was allowable when capital gains were first set off against business loss and no taxable capital gains remained; whether the assessee could use the deduction to augment a carried-forward loss.

Analysis: The deduction under section 80T was held to be available only out of gross total income and only where there were taxable capital gains. Once the capital gains were set off against the business loss under section 71(2), no taxable capital gains survived for the purpose of section 80T. The provision was treated as one granting abatement of taxable capital gains and not as a step in the computation of capital gains itself. On that footing, the assessee could not claim the deduction merely to create or enlarge a loss for carry forward.

Conclusion: Deduction under section 80T was not allowable in the absence of taxable capital gains, and the assessee's claim was rejected.

---