Trading loss deductible where cash stolen during business funding for securities purchase had direct business nexus.

A loss of cash by theft was treated as a deductible trading loss where the money had been borrowed for business use and carried in cash to purchase Government securities. The Supreme Court applied the principle that a loss, even if not expressly covered by a deduction provision, is allowable when it arises directly from the carrying on of the business and is incidental to it. Because the theft occurred during that business operation and had a direct commercial nexus, the loss was not regarded as a capital or idle-money loss. The assessee's claim succeeded and the loss was held deductible in computing taxable profits.

---

---

Issues: Whether a loss of cash by theft, incurred in the course of arranging funds for purchase of Government securities, was an allowable trading loss deductible in computing business income.

Analysis: The applicable principle was that a loss not specifically covered by the deduction provisions is allowable if, judged by accepted commercial practice and trading principles, it springs directly from the carrying on of the business and is incidental to it. The absence of an express provision for theft loss in the computation sections did not matter if the loss had the requisite business nexus. On the facts found, the money was borrowed for business use, brought to the business place in cash for purchase of securities, and a part of it was stolen during that business operation. The loss was therefore directly connected with and incidental to the business activity of acquiring securities for profit, and not a mere capital or idle-money loss.

Conclusion: The loss was an allowable trading loss and the answer was in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded, the High Court's view was set aside, and the disputed loss was held deductible in computing the assessee's taxable profits.

Ratio Decidendi: A loss is deductible as a trading loss if it has a direct and proximate connection with the business operation and is incidental to the carrying on of that business, even though no specific deduction provision expressly covers the loss.

---