1999 (11) TMI 104 - AT - Income Tax

Trust's Tax Exemption Denied for Lack of Charity Work & Improper Income Use

Al-madeena Charitable Trust. Versus Assistant Commissioner Of Income-Tax

Al-madeena Charitable Trust. Versus Assistant Commissioner Of Income-Tax - ITD 076, 214, TTJ 071, 581, Issues Involved:1. Charitable Status of the Trust.2. Application of Sections 11, 12, and 13 of the Income-tax Act.3. Use of Voluntary Contributions.4. Business Activities and Income Utilization.5. Applicability of Section 11(4A).6. Depreciation and Deductions.Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:1. Charitable Status of the Trust:The primary issue was whether the trust could be considered a charitable trust for income-tax purposes. The Assessing Officer (AO) noted that although the trust's objectives were charitable, it had not engaged in any charitable activities from its inception in 1985 until 1994. Instead, the trust was involved in the business of printing and publishing a newspaper called 'Madhyamam'. The AO held that the trust did not act in accordance with its stated charitable purposes and thus could not be treated as a charitable trust.2. Application of Sections 11, 12, and 13 of the Income-tax Act:The AO argued that even if the trust were considered charitable, its income would not be exempt under sections 11, 12, and 13. The AO pointed out several violations, including the direct use of donations for business activities, failure to invest funds as specified under section 11(5), and accumulation of income for business purposes rather than charitable activities. The CIT(A) concurred, noting that the trust had not complied with the necessary conditions to qualify for exemption under section 11.3. Use of Voluntary Contributions:The AO contended that the voluntary contributions received by the trust were used for business purposes and not for charitable activities. The CIT(A) upheld this view, stating that the contributions were diverted for acquiring assets related to the printing business and making advances to other entities, which did not align with the trust's charitable objectives.4. Business Activities and Income Utilization:The AO observed that the trust was engaged in business activities, specifically printing and publishing a newspaper, and did not utilize its income for charitable purposes. The CIT(A) agreed, noting that the trust's activities were limited to business operations and did not include any charitable work as outlined in the trust deed.5. Applicability of Section 11(4A):The AO and CIT(A) both held that section 11(4A) was applicable, which states that income from business activities is not exempt unless the business is incidental to the attainment of the trust's objectives and separate books of account are maintained. The CIT(A) concluded that the trust's business activities were not incidental to its charitable objectives and thus did not qualify for exemption.6. Depreciation and Deductions:The assessee argued that the AO had not allowed deductions under sections 28 to 43 of the Act, including depreciation. The CIT(A) noted that the AO had granted depreciation and directed him to review the matter further. However, the primary issue remained the trust's failure to engage in charitable activities, making it ineligible for the claimed exemptions.Conclusion:The Tribunal upheld the findings of the AO and CIT(A), concluding that the trust had not engaged in any charitable activities and had used its income for business purposes. The voluntary contributions were not utilized for charitable purposes, and the trust did not comply with the conditions required for exemption under sections 11, 12, and 13. The appeals filed by the assessee were dismissed.