Hawala commission addition fails when books, banking evidence and stock records support genuine transactions and no nexus is proved.

An addition for alleged hawala commission is unsustainable where the assessee's regular books, quantitative stock records, purchase and sale documents, bank entries, octroi papers and transport evidence support the transactions, and sales are received through account-payee cheques. Suspicion, conjecture, and the non-traceability of some purchaser parties are insufficient without tangible material proving that the assessee actually received commission or adopted a colourable device. Where the Revenue fails to establish a direct nexus between the primary facts and the alleged undisclosed income, the addition cannot be upheld and is liable to be deleted.

---

---

Issues: Whether the addition made on account of alleged hawala commission was sustainable on the basis of the materials relied upon by the Revenue.

Analysis: The assessee maintained quantitative stock records, purchase and sale documents, bank records, octroi and transport evidence, and the sales were received through account-payee cheques. The Assessing Officer did not bring any tangible evidence to show that the assessee had actually received hawala commission or had adopted a colourable device. The adverse inference was founded mainly on suspicion, conjecture and the non-traceability of some purchaser parties, while the remand material and confirmations of several parties supported the genuineness of the transactions. The absence of a proved nexus between the primary facts and the alleged commission income rendered the addition unsustainable.

Conclusion: The addition of hawala commission was not justified and was rightly deleted.

Ratio Decidendi: An addition cannot be sustained on surmises alone where the assessee's transactions are supported by regular books, quantitative records and banking evidence, unless the Revenue establishes by tangible material a direct nexus between the primary facts and the alleged undisclosed income.

---