Integral inputs for manufacture include research and factory support goods when commercially necessary for effective production.

Materials used in a research laboratory were treated as goods required for use in manufacture because the research was directly connected with production, plant improvement, import substitution and development of new fibre variants, making it commercially necessary for effective manufacture. Electrical goods used for factory lighting, including tubes, bulbs, fans and spares, were also treated as goods required for use in manufacture because factory operations depended on them as part of the manufacturing environment. On that footing, the disallowance was held unsustainable and the disputed items were directed to be included in the recognition certificate for consequential action.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether materials for the research laboratory were goods required for use in the manufacture of taxable goods for sale. (ii) Whether electrical goods used for lighting the factory, including fluorescent tubes, bulbs, fans and their spares, were goods required for use in the manufacture of taxable goods for sale.

Issue (i): Whether materials for the research laboratory were goods required for use in the manufacture of taxable goods for sale.

Analysis: The research activity was directed not to abstract inquiry but to the development and improvement of polyester fibre, modification of plant and machinery, import substitution, blending techniques and the evolution of new fibre variants suited to industrial demand. The process of research was held to be directly related to actual production and commercially necessary in the context of the industry. A process need not itself be the final act of producing goods if it is so integrally connected with manufacture that commercial production would be inexpedient without it.

Conclusion: The materials for the research laboratory were goods required for use in the manufacture of taxable goods for sale, in favour of the assessee.

Issue (ii): Whether electrical goods used for lighting the factory, including fluorescent tubes, bulbs, fans and their spares, were goods required for use in the manufacture of taxable goods for sale.

Analysis: Electrical equipment used for lighting and similar factory operations was treated as commercially necessary in the present stage of industrial development, and as part of the manufacturing environment needed to carry on production effectively. Goods facilitating the manufacturing process in normal industrial conditions were held to fall within the expression covering goods used in manufacture.

Conclusion: The electrical goods used for lighting the factory were goods required for use in the manufacture of taxable goods for sale, in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The disallowance was unsustainable and the disputed items were directed to be included in the recognition certificate, with the matter sent back for consequential action.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods used in a process that is directly and integrally connected with production, and commercially necessary for carrying on manufacture in the existing industrial conditions, are goods used in the manufacture of taxable goods for sale.

---