Trading receipt on cancellation of land agreement taxed as revenue income, not capital gain

Compensation received for cancellation of a land-purchase agreement was taxable as revenue income because the surrounding dealings, the agreement's development-oriented terms, and the assessee's recurring land activity showed an adventure in the nature of trade rather than a passive investment in agricultural land. The payment arose from relinquishment of contractual rights in the ordinary course of business and had no nexus with a capital asset or capital apparatus, so it could not be treated as capital receipt or capital gain. The appellate relief was reversed and the revenue's appeal succeeded.

---

---

Issues: Whether compensation received on cancellation of an agreement to purchase agricultural lands was taxable as business income or revenue receipt, and not exempt as a capital receipt or capital gain.

Analysis: The assessee's prior dealings in land, the nature of the agreement, and the surrounding circumstances showed that the transaction was part of a recurring land-development activity and not a passive investment in agricultural land. The agreement itself contemplated development and non-agricultural use, and the cancellation payment was made for relinquishment of contractual rights arising in the ordinary course of such business activity. Applying the principle that a payment received for termination of a trading contract is a trading receipt when it has no nexus with a capital asset or capital apparatus, the amount could not be treated as compensation for loss of agricultural land as such.

Conclusion: The receipt was taxable as revenue income arising from an adventure in the nature of trade and was not a capital receipt or capital gain.

Final Conclusion: The revenue's appeal succeeded and the relief granted by the appellate authority was reversed.

Ratio Decidendi: Compensation received for cancellation of a contract entered into in the ordinary course of business is a revenue receipt when it arises from relinquishment of contractual rights and has no nexus with a capital asset.

---