1988 (6) TMI 55 - AT - Income Tax

Invalid Exercise of Revisional Jurisdiction under Section 263

The Tribunal found the Commissioner of Income-tax's exercise of revisional jurisdiction under section 263 invalid as it relied on material collected ... Revision Of Order, Order Prejudicial To Interests Of Revenue, Capital Gains, Exemption In Certain Cases Issues Involved:1. Validity of the exercise of revisional jurisdiction under section 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961.2. Communication and effectiveness of assessment orders.3. Jurisdictional infirmity due to reliance on material collected post-assessment.4. Ownership and character of the acquired property.5. Application of section 54E regarding investment in National Rural Development Bonds.Detailed Analysis:1. Validity of the Exercise of Revisional Jurisdiction under Section 263:The Commissioner of Income-tax (CIT) exercised his powers under section 263 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, to set aside the assessments made by the Income-tax Officer (ITO) for the assessment year 1981-82, requiring fresh orders. The CIT deemed the ITO's orders erroneous and prejudicial to the interests of revenue, arguing the capital gain on the acquisition of agricultural land should be taxed in the case of the deceased appellant, Sri V. O. Mehta, in his individual capacity. However, the Tribunal found the CIT's exercise of revisional jurisdiction invalid as it relied on material gathered from 'further enquiries' post-assessment, which is impermissible under section 263.2. Communication and Effectiveness of Assessment Orders:The appellants argued that the assessment orders were never communicated to some of them, specifically late Sri V. O. Mehta and Smt. Nirmalaben V. Mehta. The Tribunal supported this argument, emphasizing that an order must be communicated to be effective and enforceable. The Tribunal cited relevant case law, including CIT v. Oriental Rubber Works, to support the necessity of communication for the validity of an order. The lack of communication rendered the CIT's revisional actions invalid.3. Jurisdictional Infirmity Due to Reliance on Material Collected Post-Assessment:The Tribunal noted that the CIT's reliance on 'further enquiries' conducted after the original assessment was a jurisdictional error. The Tribunal cited several cases, including Ganga Properties v. ITO and CIT v. Shriram Development Co., to emphasize that revisional jurisdiction under section 263 must be based on the record as it stood at the time of the original assessment. The CIT's actions were thus found to be invalid due to this foundational defect.4. Ownership and Character of the Acquired Property:The CIT contended that the agricultural land was the exclusive property of the late Sri V. O. Mehta and not ancestral property. However, the Tribunal found substantial evidence supporting the appellants' claim that the land was ancestral, including partnership deeds, applications to revenue authorities, and entries in village forms. The Tribunal concluded that the land retained its ancestral character despite any changes in recorded ownership, thus invalidating the CIT's assessment of the land as the deceased appellant's exclusive property.5. Application of Section 54E Regarding Investment in National Rural Development Bonds:The appellants had invested the compensation received from the land acquisition in National Rural Development Bonds within six months, as required under section 54E. The CIT argued that section 54E required investment by 'an' assessee and not by others on their behalf. The Tribunal rejected this interpretation, stating that if the CIT considered the deceased appellant as the recipient of the entire compensation, the investments made by others should also be deemed as made on his behalf. The Tribunal emphasized a reasonable construction of section 54E to avoid absurdity and ensure the legislative intent was met.Conclusion:The Tribunal set aside the CIT's orders under section 263, finding them invalid both in law and on facts. The appeals were allowed, and the original assessments by the ITO were reinstated.