Fresh show cause notice required for recovery of refunded excise amount; recovery without it was unsustainable.

Recovery of a refunded excise amount required a fresh show cause notice under Section 11A, because the Department sought to recoup money after refund disbursement and the earlier refund order had been reversed. The Tribunal treated the prior adjudication as having already concluded the substantive packing-value dispute against the assessee, so the remaining question was only the legality of recovery. In the absence of a valid notice within the prescribed time, recovery of the refunded amount was not sustainable. The packing material issue was also noted as having been decided against exclusion from assessable value.

---

---

Issues: Whether, in the circumstances of the case, the Department could recover an amount already refunded without issuing a fresh show cause notice under Section 11A, and whether the packing material in question was returnable so as to exclude its cost from the assessable value.

Analysis: The refund had been sanctioned after adjudication of a show cause notice that proposed rejection of the claim, but the order granting refund was later set aside on departmental challenge. The Tribunal noted that the earlier proceedings had already concluded against the assessee on the substantive packing-value issue, and the remaining question was the mode of recovery of the amount already paid. For recovery of an amount that had actually been refunded, a separate notice under Section 11A was necessary within the prescribed time, because the Department sought to recover an amount after the refund had been disbursed and the prior adjudication order had been reversed. The absence of such notice barred recovery.

Conclusion: The recovery of the refunded amount without a valid show cause notice under Section 11A was not sustainable, and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

---