Capital goods credit under Rule 57Q depends on functional use in manufacture; civil works and support structures do not qualify.

Under Rule 57Q, capital goods credit depends on whether the item itself satisfies the statutory definition and is functionally used in manufacture. A transformer below 75 KVA used in the manufacturing process was held eligible for credit because the lower-capacity transformer was not excluded by the definition and remained a qualifying capital good. Cement, TOR steel and steel structures used in foundations and as conveyor supports were held ineligible because they formed part of civil construction or mere supporting structures, not machinery, plant, equipment or their components.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether transformer of power handling capacity below 75 KVA was eligible for capital goods credit under Rule 57Q; (ii) Whether cement, TOR steel and steel structures used in foundation work and for installation of conveyors were eligible for capital goods credit.

Issue (i): Whether transformer of power handling capacity below 75 KVA was eligible for capital goods credit under Rule 57Q.

Analysis: The transformer was used in the manufacture of the respondents' goods, and the definition of capital goods in the Explanation to Rule 57Q was construed in light of the Supreme Court's ruling that goods used in the manufacturing process qualify where they are covered by the definition and are functionally used in the factory. The exclusion for higher-capacity transformers did not displace eligibility of transformers below 75 KVA when they were used for producing or processing goods.

Conclusion: The transformer below 75 KVA was eligible for capital goods credit and the Revenue's appeal failed on this issue.

Issue (ii): Whether cement, TOR steel and steel structures used in foundation work and for installation of conveyors were eligible for capital goods credit.

Analysis: Cement and TOR steel used in foundations were part of civil construction on which machinery was installed, and therefore did not themselves become machine, machinery, plant, equipment, apparatus, tools or appliances, or their components, spare parts or accessories. The steel structures were found to be only supporting structures for the conveyor system and not parts or components of the conveyors. On that reasoning, these items fell outside the scope of capital goods under Rule 57Q.

Conclusion: Cement, TOR steel and steel structures were not eligible for capital goods credit and the Revenue's appeal succeeded on these issues.

Final Conclusion: The decision upheld credit only for the transformer below 75 KVA and denied credit for the civil-construction and support-structure items.

Ratio Decidendi: Under Rule 57Q of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, eligibility for capital goods credit depends on whether the item itself answers the statutory definition and is functionally used in manufacture; items used only in civil construction or as mere support structures do not qualify.

---