Finality of adjudication order barred automatic recovery of Modvat credit despite validating legislation.

The Revenue could not appropriate Modvat credit from sanctioned refunds where the adjudication order allowing the credit had attained finality and was never challenged. Section 112 of the Finance Act, 2000 validated denial of credit for the relevant period, but it did not by itself annul the earlier allowance or authorise automatic recovery. Recovery had to be pursued separately in accordance with law. The Revenue was therefore restricted to appropriating only the amount lawfully recoverable under the existing adjudication and confirmed penalty, and not the full credit amount originally allowed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Revenue could appropriate from the sanctioned refunds the amount of Modvat credit of Rs. 9,31,904 allowed by the Deputy Commissioner under an adjudication order that had attained finality, and whether Section 112 of the Finance Act, 2000 automatically reversed that allowance.

Analysis: The amount of credit allowed by the Deputy Commissioner was never challenged by the Revenue and therefore had attained finality. Section 11 of the Central Excise Act permits recovery of sums due by deduction from money owing, but it does not authorise recovery of an amount merely because it was later covered by a validating provision when the original allowance has not been set aside. Section 112 of the Finance Act, 2000 validated denial of credit for the relevant period, but it did not by itself annul the adjudication order allowing credit; separate recovery action in accordance with law was required. The Revenue could, therefore, appropriate only the amount lawfully recoverable on the basis of the existing adjudication and confirmed penalty.

Conclusion: The Revenue was not entitled to appropriate Rs. 9,31,904 from the sanctioned refunds. It could appropriate only Rs. 13,14,060 towards duty and Rs. 10,000 towards penalty. The appeals were disposed of accordingly.

---