Capital goods eligibility under Modvat Rule 57Q sustained for factory pneumatic conveying equipment and its parts.

Pneumatic Conveying System used within the factory for unloading and handling fly ash qualified as material-handling equipment and fell within the Chapter 84 description of capital goods under Rule 57Q, so Modvat credit was allowable. Its parts, spares and accessories were also eligible. The invoice described the goods under Heading 84.14, and the later corrigendum supported that the goods had been duly declared. The lower appellate authority could not deny credit by independently reclassifying the goods under Chapter 87 when the proper classification had already been adopted by the manufacturer. The denial of credit was therefore unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether the Pneumatic Conveying System and its parts were eligible capital goods for Modvat credit under Rule 57Q, and whether the denial of credit could be sustained on the grounds of tariff classification and alleged defect in declaration.

Analysis: The goods were shown in the manufacturer's invoice under Heading 84.14 and were not established to be compressors of the excluded kind used in refrigerating or air-conditioning machinery. The later corrigendum to the declaration supported the assessee's claim that the goods were duly declared, and the lower appellate authority could not itself reclassify the goods under Chapter 87 when the proper classification had already been adopted at the manufacturer's end. On the facts, the system was used in the factory for unloading and handling fly ash, which made it a material-handling equipment used within the factory. Goods falling under Chapter 84, and their components, spares and accessories, were within the relevant capital goods description in Rule 57Q.

Conclusion: The Pneumatic Conveying System was eligible for Modvat credit under Rule 57Q, and its parts were also eligible; the disallowance of credit was not sustainable.

Ratio Decidendi: Material-handling equipment used within the factory for handling raw material, and falling within the eligible Chapter 84 category, qualifies as capital goods for Modvat credit under Rule 57Q, and the lower authority cannot deny such credit by independently reclassifying the goods contrary to the proper classification.

---