Share premium in reserves can count toward paid-up capital when the account remains identifiable for rebate reduction

Share premium credited to an identifiable separate account was includible in paid-up capital for computing reduction of rebate in super-tax under the relevant Finance Acts. The Court held that the expression "paid-up capital" covered premiums received in cash and standing to the credit of the share premium account, and the statute did not require that such account be kept outside reserves unless the governing enactment expressly said so. For the earlier assessment year, the pre-1956 company law regime applied and the 1956 Companies Act was not retrospective. The company's appeals therefore failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether share premium retained as an identifiable part of the reserves could be included in the paid-up capital for computing reduction of rebate in super-tax under the Finance Acts of 1956 and 1957.

Analysis: The reduction of rebate under the Finance Acts depended upon the extent to which dividends exceeded the prescribed percentage of the company's paid-up capital. The expression "paid-up capital" in the relevant Explanation included premiums received in cash and standing to the credit of the share premium account. For the assessment year 1956-57, the company was governed by the earlier company law regime, under which there was no requirement that share premium be kept in a separate account outside reserves, and the 1956 Companies Act did not operate retrospectively. For the assessment year 1957-58, the Explanation in the Finance Act, 1957 was held to use the same expression in the same sense, and it did not require that the share premium account be maintained outside the reserves. What mattered was that the share premium formed an identifiable separate account.

Conclusion: Share premium maintained as an identifiable part of the reserves was includible in paid-up capital for the purpose of computing rebate reduction, and the appeals failed.

Ratio Decidendi: For computing rebate reduction under the relevant Finance Acts, share premium is includible in paid-up capital if it is maintained as an identifiable separate account, and the statute does not require that such account must lie outside the reserves unless the governing enactment expressly so provides.

---