Aluminium cut-pieces as excisable waste and scrap upheld; penalty deleted for lack of supporting finding.

Aluminium cut-pieces arising from the manufacture of excisable final products, which were marketable and not usable as such after cutting, were treated as excisable waste and scrap under Note 8(a) to Section XV and classifiable under Chapter Sub-Heading 7602.90 rather than the in-factory scrap entry. The plea that no manufacture was involved was rejected, and the duty demand was upheld. The penalty, however, could not stand because the appellate record contained no supporting finding to sustain it in law, so it was deleted.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the aluminium cut-pieces cleared by the assessee were excisable as waste and scrap under the tariff and the Section Note; (ii) whether the penalty imposed could be sustained.

Issue (i): Whether the aluminium cut-pieces cleared by the assessee were excisable as waste and scrap under the tariff and the Section Note.

Analysis: The cut-pieces arose from the same process by which the assessee manufactured excisable final products from duty-paid aluminium inputs. They were admittedly sold in the market and were not usable as such after cutting. On these facts, the goods answered the description of waste and scrap under Note 8(a) to Section XV and were classifiable under the residual tariff entry for aluminium waste and scrap, rather than the entry for scrap used within the factory for manufacture of unwrought aluminium plates and sheets. The plea that no manufacture was involved was rejected.

Conclusion: The cut-pieces were correctly held dutiable as aluminium waste and scrap under Chapter Sub-Heading 7602.90.

Issue (ii): Whether the penalty imposed could be sustained.

Analysis: The appellate record did not contain a finding supporting the penalty imposed by the adjudicating authority. In the absence of such a finding, the penalty could not be sustained in law.

Conclusion: The penalty was not sustainable and was set aside.

Final Conclusion: The duty demand was upheld, but the penalty was deleted, resulting in a partial success for the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Aluminium cut-pieces that arise from the manufacture of final products, are marketable, and are not usable as such may be treated as excisable waste and scrap under the relevant tariff entry; a penalty cannot survive without a supporting finding.

---