Clubbing of minor's partnership income requires proof that the income arose from transferred assets; mere family linkage is insufficient.

Income can be clubbed under section 16(3)(a)(iv) only if the minor's share income directly or indirectly arises from assets transferred by the assessee. Mere admission of a minor to the benefits of partnership, or the existence of allied firms with financial connections, is insufficient unless a real nexus between the transferred assets and the income is proved. On the facts stated, there was no cogent basis to attribute the profits from the Galla and Calcutta firms to the father's gifted capital, and no evidence that the Dhubri firm share arose because capital was introduced as a condition of admission. The share income was therefore not includible in the father's assessment.

---

---

Issues: Whether the share income of a minor admitted to the benefits of partnership in the concerned firms was liable to be included in the father's assessment under section 16(3)(a)(iv) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922.

Analysis: The provision applies only where the minor's income is a benefit directly or indirectly arising from assets transferred by the assessee. Mere admission of the minor to the benefits of partnership, or the existence of allied firms with financial connections, is insufficient unless a real nexus between the transferred assets and the income is established. On the facts, the Court found no cogent basis to treat the profits from the Galla and Calcutta firms as attributable to the capital gifted by the father, and also found no evidence that the minor's share in the Dhubri firm arose because the capital was introduced as a condition of admission to the firm. The absence of a proved linkage between the gift and the disputed share income was ative.

Conclusion: The share income was not includible in the father's assessment under section 16(3)(a)(iv), and the decision was in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Income can be clubbed under section 16(3)(a)(iv) only when it directly or indirectly arises from assets transferred by the assessee; a mere family arrangement, admission to partnership benefits, or allied business connection does not suffice without proof of the requisite nexus.

---