Undervaluation in customs valuation upheld where manufacturer's price list rebutted the declared import value.

Customs authorities may rely on a manufacturer's price list to test the truth of the declared transaction value where it appears inconsistent with the invoice value. Here, the price list showed a substantially higher value, the goods bore markings matching that list, and the importer produced no documentary evidence to prove a claimed discount or any reduction from the manufacturer's listed price. A prima facie case of undervaluation was therefore established, and the burden shifted to the importer to rebut it. As no satisfactory rebuttal was made, reassessment of the imported goods' value on the basis of the manufacturer's price list was upheld and the differential duty demand remained in force.

---

---

Issues: Whether the enhancement of assessable value of imported goods on the basis of the manufacturer's price list was justified and the appeal against the order confirming differential duty was liable to be dismissed.

Analysis: The Customs authorities were entitled to call for and rely upon the manufacturer's price list under the valuation rules to test the truth of the declared transaction value. On the facts, the price list showed a much higher price than the invoice value, the markings on the goods matched the price list, and the appellants produced no documentary material to support the claim of a substantial discount or any reduction in the manufacturer's price. Once a prima facie case of undervaluation was established, the burden shifted to the appellants to rebut it, which they failed to do. The valuation fixed on the basis of the available manufacturer's price list could not be faulted.

Conclusion: The enhancement of value was upheld and the appeal failed.

Final Conclusion: The customs valuation based on the manufacturer's price list stood affirmed, with the resulting duty demand remaining in force.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the declared import value is contradicted by reliable material such as the manufacturer's price list and the importer fails to rebut a prima facie case of undervaluation, the value may be reassessed on that basis under the customs valuation rules.

---