Capital goods test under Modvat failed for steel support structures used in furnace fabrication and movement assistance.

Steel items used to fabricate skid rails, skid tubes and stands for furnace operation did not qualify as capital goods or as parts, components, spares or accessories of the furnace under Rule 57Q. The fabricated structures merely facilitated holding and movement of material into the furnace, while the furnace remained complete without them; their wear and replacement did not convert the inputs into eligible consumables. The authorities followed the principle that steel used for construction or support structures, rather than integral machinery parts, falls outside Modvat credit eligibility. Credit was therefore denied and that denial was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether mild steel twisted bars, shapes and sections of iron and steel, and mild steel angles used to fabricate skid rails, skid tubes and stands for furnace operation were eligible for Modvat credit as capital goods or their components under Rule 57Q.

Analysis: The inputs were used in the fabrication of skid rails, skid tubes and stands that only facilitated holding and movement of material into the furnace. They were neither covered by the definition of capital goods nor could the fabricated items be treated as parts, components, spares or accessories of the furnace. The furnace was complete without them, and their wear and eventual replacement did not make the inputs consumables eligible for credit. The authorities relied on the earlier view that steel items used in construction or support structures not directly forming part of machinery were outside Rule 57Q, while the decisions cited by the assessee concerned distinguishable facts involving integral parts of machinery or plant.

Conclusion: The inputs were not admissible for Modvat credit under Rule 57Q and the denial of credit was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Steel items used merely to fabricate support or facilitating structures that are not integral parts, components, spares or accessories of furnace machinery do not qualify as capital goods for Modvat credit under Rule 57Q.

---