Tariff classification of mis-rolls turns on re-rollability: directly hot-rollable scrap is not waste and scrap.

Mis-rolls arising during CTD bar manufacture, if directly usable in smaller hot re-rolling mills without remelting, are not "waste and scrap" under tariff heading 72.04. The applicable Board circular limited heading 72.04 to goods generally used for remelting and excluded re-rollable scrap or articles convertible into another product by hot rolling. On that basis, such mis-rolls were treated as semi-finished products under heading 72.07, and the Revenue's classification was sustained; the duty demand remained upheld and the penalty and interest issues were not disturbed.

---

---

Issues: Whether mis-rolls arising during the manufacture of CTD bars were classifiable under tariff heading 72.04 as waste and scrap, or under tariff heading 72.07 as semi-finished products.

Analysis: The mis-rolls emerged during re-rolling and were capable of being directly used in smaller hot re-rolling mills without first being melted. The Board circular relied upon by the Court clarified that heading 72.04 covers only waste and scrap generally used for remelting and does not extend to re-rollable scrap or articles that can be converted into another article by hot rolling without remelting. On that basis, the Tribunal's view that the goods were semi-finished products under heading 72.07 was affirmed.

Conclusion: The mis-rolls were not classifiable under heading 72.04 and were correctly classifiable under heading 72.07, so the classification adopted by the Revenue was upheld against the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal failed and the duty demand on the disputed classification remained sustained, while the penalty and interest issues were not disturbed by the final dismissal.

Ratio Decidendi: Re-rollable scrap or mis-rolls that can be directly hot-rolled into another product without remelting are not waste and scrap under heading 72.04 and are classifiable under the appropriate semi-finished heading.

---