Brand name test for excise classification: descriptive packet wording and mandatory manufacturer details do not create branded goods.

For excise classification under Chapter 20, sub-heading 2001.10 applied only to preparations in unit containers bearing a brand name, meaning a mark, symbol, name or similar device used in trade to indicate a connection with a person. A merely descriptive expression identifying the contents of the packet did not satisfy that test, and the manufacturer's required name and address on the packaging did not by itself make the goods branded. The expression on the French fries packets was therefore not a brand name, so the goods were not classifiable under sub-heading 2001.10 and the assessee succeeded.

---

---

Issues: Whether the expression printed on the French fries packets constituted a brand name so as to make the goods classifiable under sub-heading 2001.10 of Chapter 20 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Analysis: Sub-heading 2001.10 applied only to preparations put up in unit containers and bearing a brand name, whereas sub-heading 2001.90 covered other goods. A brand name, for this purpose, must be a mark, symbol, name or similar device used in relation to the product so as to indicate a connection in the course of trade between the product and a person. A merely descriptive expression that identifies the contents of the packet does not satisfy that test. The presence of the manufacturer's name on the packet could not, by itself, convert every unit container into branded goods, particularly when the statutory packaging regime required the manufacturer's name and address to be declared on packets.

Conclusion: The expression on the packets was not a brand name, and the goods without that expression were not classifiable under sub-heading 2001.10. The appeals were therefore allowed and the assessee succeeded.

Ratio Decidendi: For tariff classification as branded goods, the mark or name must be distinctive of the product and must establish a trade connection with a person; a purely descriptive phrase or the manufacturer's required name on the packet is not, by itself, a brand name.

---