Section 68 addition on alleged penny stock trades deleted where documentary evidence and no assessee-specific adverse material supported genuineness.

Addition under section 68 based on alleged penny stock transactions was deleted because the assessee produced purchase and sale records, broker confirmations, bank trail and demat-linked material showing genuine business dealings. The Revenue relied on general Investigation Wing information but made no independent verification or assessee-specific adverse enquiry, so the unexplained cash credit allegation was not sustained. The order also noted that the actual sale value was lower than the figure adopted by the Assessing Officer and that the trades were of short duration, which weakened the case for accommodation entry or price rigging.

---

---

Issues: Whether the addition made under section 68 on the basis of alleged penny stock transactions and Investigation Wing information was sustainable.

Analysis: The assessee had shown the share dealings as business transactions and produced documentary evidence such as purchase and sale records, broker confirmation, bank trail and demat-related material. The addition was made by treating the sale value as unexplained cash credit on the strength of general investigation material, but the revenue authorities did not carry out any independent verification or bring adverse material specifically against the assessee. The order also noted that the actual sale value was lower than the figure adopted by the Assessing Officer and that the transactions were short-duration trades, which weakened the allegation of accommodation entry or price rigging.

Conclusion: The addition under section 68 was deleted and the assessee succeeded.

---