Jurisdictional grounds on assessment validity and section 147 were admitted and remanded for factual adjudication.

Additional jurisdictional grounds challenging the validity of the assessment on transfer of jurisdiction, change of assessing officer, and the alleged inapplicability of section 147 to material found in the search of another person were admitted because they went to the root of the assessment. As resolution depended on records and factual verification, including whether jurisdiction had been validly transferred and whether a written order was required, the matter involved a mixed question of fact and law. The Tribunal therefore considered it appropriate for the first appellate authority to examine the grounds first and remitted them for adjudication in accordance with law.

---

---

Issues: Whether the assessee's additional jurisdictional grounds could be admitted for the first time before the Tribunal and whether those grounds should be remanded to the first appellate authority for adjudication.

Analysis: The additional grounds raised a challenge to the validity of the assessment on jurisdictional and procedural footing, including transfer of jurisdiction, change of incumbent assessing officer, and the alleged inapplicability of assessment under section 147 where the dispute related to material found in a search of another person. As these were legal issues going to the root of the assessment, they were admitted. At the same time, their disposal required examination of records and factual verification as to whether jurisdiction was transferred, whether a written order was required, which authority was competent, and whether the assessment was made according to law. Since the issue involved a mixed question of fact and law, it was considered appropriate that the first appellate authority first examine the matter.

Conclusion: The additional grounds were admitted and remanded to the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) for adjudication in accordance with law.

---