Customs valuation excludes buying commissions, licence fees and routine management fees when they are not conditions of sale.

Customs valuation under Section 14 of the Customs Act and the Customs Valuation Rules permits adoption of the price actually paid or payable where the buyer and seller are unrelated and price is the sole consideration. On that basis, the proposed transaction value for imported finished goods from third-party manufacturers was accepted. Buying agent fees paid to overseas procurement agents were treated as buying commissions and excluded from value. Licence fees for brand, intellectual property, store design and retail know-how were excluded because they were not conditions of sale and lacked nexus with the import price. Management fees for routine inter-company services were also excluded as independent post-import support costs.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether the proposed transaction value for imported finished goods from unrelated third-party manufacturers is acceptable under the customs valuation framework; (ii) whether the buying agent fee paid to overseas procurement agents is includible in the transaction value; (iii) whether the license fee paid for brand and intellectual property rights is includible in the transaction value; (iv) whether the management fee paid for routine inter-company services is includible in the transaction value.

Issue (i): Whether the proposed transaction value for imported finished goods from unrelated third-party manufacturers is acceptable under the customs valuation framework.

Analysis: The valuation scheme under Section 14 of the Customs Act, 1962 and Rules 2 and 3 of the Customs Valuation Rules, 2007 accepts the price actually paid or payable where the buyer and seller are not related and price is the sole consideration. The imported goods were sourced from third-party manufacturers, the title and risk passed directly to the importer, and the record did not show that the sellers were related persons within Rule 2. The proposed value for conversion-based imports and FOB-based imports was found to represent the actual consideration for the goods.

Conclusion: The proposed transaction value is acceptable and may be adopted for customs valuation.

Issue (ii): Whether the buying agent fee paid to overseas procurement agents is includible in the transaction value.

Analysis: Rule 10 adds commissions and brokerage to the transaction value, but expressly excludes buying commissions. The service arrangement showed that the agents sourced vendors, placed purchase orders, facilitated payments, did not take title, did not bear risk, and were compensated separately for procurement services. The fee was for representing the importer abroad in purchasing the goods and was not part of the price paid to the seller.

Conclusion: The buying agent fee is a buying commission and is not includible in the transaction value.

Issue (iii): Whether the license fee paid for brand and intellectual property rights is includible in the transaction value.

Analysis: Royalty or license fee is includible only when it relates to the imported goods and is payable as a condition of the sale. The license arrangement concerned brand exploitation, store design, know-how, and retail operations after importation, and the importer's right to purchase the goods was not conditional on payment of the fee. The fee was linked to domestic retail sales, not to the import transaction, and had no nexus with the price charged by the foreign manufacturers.

Conclusion: The license fee is not includible in the transaction value.

Issue (iv): Whether the management fee paid for routine inter-company services is includible in the transaction value.

Analysis: Payments are added under Rule 10 only when they are made as a condition of sale or to satisfy the seller's obligation. The management services were ordinary back-office and business-support services, independent of the import of goods, and the fee was payable irrespective of whether imports were made. It was not payable to the seller and had no nexus with the imported merchandise.

Conclusion: The management fee is not includible in the transaction value.

Final Conclusion: The customs valuation proposed by the applicant was accepted, and the impugned ancillary payments were held to be outside the assessable value of the imported goods.

Ratio Decidendi: Under Section 14 and Rules 3 and 10 of the Customs Valuation Rules, only payments forming part of the price for the imported goods, or made as a condition of sale and having a direct nexus with the imported goods, are includible in transaction value; buying commissions and post-importation or independent service fees are excluded.

---